“Sure as fuck feels like it,” Levi said, the mirror on the visor down as he took his time applying his eyeliner. He heaved out a sharp breath. “It was like a full bodysnatch, ever since she found Brad and found religion. Like…she always tried to fit in a little more than me, don’t get me wrong. But Kelly used to have my back during high school. We used to hit the movies every weekend, used to go on stupid long drives to the middle of nowhere to scream at the stars.”
Damn. My heart squeezed hard. This was a little too close to home for me. “Not every memory of my dad was bad,” I admitted, even though the words came out in a rasp. Levi remained quiet, so I seized the impetus to continue. “He’s the one who taught me how to draw originally. We’d just sit there in the living room sketching out landscapes or animals or whatever the hell we wanted, and eventually I got better and better. But then one day, me and Mom weren’t enough. At least, not when it came to the lure of gambling. And he left.”
Levi spat a curse. “Why do people have to be so horrible?”
I chewed on my lower lip and chanced a glance at him. “They’re not all bad, I guess.”
His hand settled on my thigh, and he squeezed. “No, no, they’re not.”
My throat squeezed tight, and my heart thumped out of control. God, what was he doing to me? This was so different from how I’d felt about anyone in the past. Maybe a little because I’d started to let him in, but he’d gotten past my defenses in the first place. I punched on the radio to keep from rambling more. My mind detoured in dangerous directions, ones I didn’t want to address right before his sister’s shower.
The Offspring blared from the speakers, a welcome distraction, even though the fast beats fit my accelerated adrenaline.
“Shit, I love this song,” Levi said. He still hadn’t taken his hand off my thigh, and goddamn, I was burning up. But I also didn’t want to sever the connection.
“Same,” I rasped, my voice a bit hoarser than intended.
He squeezed my thigh again, and damn, I was pretty sure getting hard wouldn’t help right now, but my brain was crossing the wires of heart and…well, other head.
“Let’s play a car game,” I spat out, desperate to distract myself from either urge rearing inside me.
“Well, now I’m curious, because I wouldn’t peg you as the type who liked car games,” Levi said with a low chuckle.
“Two truths and a lie?” I said and winced. Wow, damn, that was bad even for me. However, I hadn’t let anyone in before, and this vulnerability prickling along my skin messed with my head in a real way.
“What are we, teenagers?” he teased, but I liked it. “I’ll bite, only because I’m going to catalogue every secret I find out from you. Obviously, you’re going first.”
“Right,” I muttered. This had been a dumbass idea. I glanced at the GPS, but we had about another hour in the car until we got to the shower. No way to detour out of this one. “Fine, I broke my leg trying to sled off the roof when I was seven. Uh, my first tattoo I ever did was a bright pink flamingo on my boss, Owen. And my mother and I have seen the musical Wicked at least seven times.”
“Hmm,” Levi said. “The first one, I buy—you give the throw-your-body-into-trouble sort of vibe. And given the fact that I’ve met your mother, I believe you’d do anything for her—but wouldn’t need the push because Wicked is amazing. My bet’s the flamingo is a lie.”
My heart thrummed. Well, that hadn’t toned down the intensity I was feeling. Levi read me better than anyone I’d ever met. “I did give him my first tattoo, but it was a black cat.” I paused to wet my suddenly dry lips. “Your turn.”
“Oh, ew, I already hate this,” Levi said, amusement in his tone. “What if they’re all lies?”
I arched a brow, even though I didn’t take my gaze off the road. “I did it. Telling me you can’t perform?”
“Brat,” he teased. “Okay, so I went to prom solo with a fake raven on my shoulder. Let’s see…my costume that got me noticed was a slutty version of Alucard from Castlevania. And I fucking hate kiwis. The seeds drive me nuts every time.”
I let out a low hum as I mulled it over. I’d scanned over his socials enough to know the Alucard one was true—those posts got insane views and were a bit older, when he was clearly just starting out with more serious cosplay. Not like I’d admit how much I’d looked at those pictures. “My bet is the prom situation. The kiwi thing feels too authentic.”
“Correct,” he said. “I didn’t go to prom at all.”
“Rebel, rebel,” I teased. “Wasn’t my bag either. My friends and I went out to a seventeen-and-up night at a club in the city instead.”
“Ugh, I fucking wish,” Levi said, his voice softening. “The dumb thing was that I actually wanted to go. But this area wasn’t…easy for someone like me. And if I went to prom, I’d want to do my hair and makeup, wear something gorgeous. That wouldn’t have ended well.”
My stomach hollowed out. I reached out with my right hand, my other still on the wheel, and I squeezed his thigh this time. “Hey, you’re making up for it now. People pay you to dress up, and that’s the goddamn best payback to all those shitheads at your high school. You’re fucking amazing.”
Levi was quiet for a few moments. Had I upset him? Anger simmered in me that anyone would’ve tried to dim his light, even though I wasn’t naïve. A more masc guy like me could blend a lot of times, but him? No, he’d get clocked wherever he went, and people could be assholes, especially the closer to central Pennsylvania you got.
I glanced his way. His eyes were a little glossy, but the gentle smile on his lips was stunning. Fuck, I was so smitten it was unreal.
“That might be the sweetest thing anyone’s said,” he replied, his usual flirt and sarcasm absent in the simple words. “You’re going to need to stop being so damn perfect, Caspian Lewis.”
“I’m far from that.” I shook my head, even though heat crept onto my cheeks. Somehow, Levi had etched himself into my marrow in a way I hadn’t allowed anyone before. After Dad had left and fucked me and Mom over, I’d kept those guards up, always.
“I’ll fight you on that one,” he teased, sounding a bit more like his usual flirty self. “Though I fight dirty.”