Cas pressed his lips together and sank against the counter. The truth hung heavy in the air, at least for me, that this was different from my other casual hookups. And that alone made the situation more complex.
Cas picked up his mug and took a sip of his coffee. “So, why the invitation?”
I blinked for a minute at the redirect. Apparently neither of us were ready to answer the question yet. I picked up my own mug and leaned next to him. To dodge or not? That was always the question. But he’d given me so much last night…maybe I could trust him enough to offer the truth.
“My sister and I were close growing up,” I said. “And in central PA, I needed that. It wasn’t the best place to be an out queer kid, particularly more femme.”
“In Pennsyltucky? Yeah, I can imagine,” he responded.
“Well, then she met Brad,” I said, wrinkling my nose.
“What a douchey name,” Cas responded, and my lips twitched with a grin, despite the heaviness in my chest. “Let me guess, he’s an asshole?”
“Yeah, it was like she’d gotten body snatched. Same face, same voice, but overnight, she became a god-fearing woman who didn’t tolerate sinners in her life—and that includes queer folks like me.”
“Fuck that shit,” Cas spat out, his brows drawing together. “The way people use faith like a shield for their bigotry is fucking bullshit.” He placed his cup of coffee down, his shoulders squared like he was ready to launch into a fight. “Do you know how many times I’ve had to go head-to-head with counterprotesters hiding behind a Bible and a shitty sign?”
“Okay, just keep making yourself hotter,” I commented. Though, that didn’t surprise me. Cas seemed the sort to put his body on the line, to step in defense of others. And damn, I liked that far too much.
“What does your sister have to do with yesterday, though?” he asked, his brow still creased.
I heaved a sigh. “Yeah, my parents decided to surprise both of us by getting us in a room together to announce that she’s pregnant. I fucking love kids too, but it’s not like she’ll ever let me near any of the nieces or nephews she’s going to bear.”
“Shit,” he said. “That sucks.”
“Yeah, it does.” Even though I avoided talking about my private life like crazy, telling Cas here and now offered a relief I’d been craving. I couldn’t vent to Mom and Dad. They were mired in this mess like I was, but they were stuck in the middle. And beyond Kell, a lot of my other friends were that complicated mix of industry acquaintance and not the sort I could talk about heavy stuff with, so I just skated the superficial endlessly.
Despite the friendly faces I knew from cons, a loneliness came with the notoriety and the lifestyle that I rarely talked about. And yet, this morning with Cas filled me with more warmth than I’d experienced in months…maybe even years.
And I wanted more.
“Not to derail the conversation, but Rodney sent me an email without the forms,” Cas said, his hand balling into a fist. “I’ve been going through a lot of Mom’s old files, and fuck, I think he’s just inept as hell.”
“Lucky for us, I talked to my friend Kendra, who’s a major international cosplayer but also has insane connections because she still works part-time as a lawyer.” I wasn’t sad about the subject change. The heaviness had evaporated in the mere confession of what had plagued me yesterday, and I’d been meaning to tell him the digging I’d done since I assumed Rodney wasn’t going to follow through.
“She have a suggestion for someone local?” he asked. Relief settled in me that he wasn’t giving pushback, even though I knew what a can of worms this opened for his family.
“Yeah, want me to send the inquiry?” I asked, running my fingers through my hair.
“Please,” he said. “If I like working with them on this, maybe I can broach this with my mother.” His mouth formed a firm line.
“You look excited about that,” I commented.
“The last thing I want is for her to feel taken advantage of by another fucking asshole,” he muttered.
My heart squeezed tight. The pain in his voice made those past wounds clear. Whatever his father had pulled on his way out had clearly caused a lot of problems and heartbreak. Especially if lawyers were needed this far down the line.
“We’ll test the waters with Genevieve with our divorce,” I said, even though the word tasted odd on my tongue after the night we just shared. “This should’ve been an open-and-shut case.”
“I’m realizing that,” Cas said. The wrinkle on his brow hadn’t lessened, and I hated that.
“Hey,” I said, placing a hand on his chest. “Why don’t we go get a shower?”
Cas looked up to me, and his gaze softened, as if he saw right through my attempt. “You saying I stink?”
My lips quirked. “Maybe. Or maybe I regret not getting a taste of that cock last night…”
He licked his lips and leaned in to tug at my earlobe with his teeth. A shiver rushed through me. When he pulled back, his eyes danced.