I sit down on the step beside him, with the width of a person between us, and pick up the mug. It’s hot enough to feel like a personal threat. I take a sip. It’s perfect.
“Is it right?” Oliver asks.
His voice is quiet and rough and a little unsteady. I look at his profile against the pale morning, the lines at the corner of his eye, the dark shadow on his jaw, the hands loosely clasped between his knees.
“You know it is.”
“I know what you told me,” he says. “On a stool at Hattie’s, four weeks ago. I’d like to hear what you’d say now.”
I think about it. I really do. I hold the warm ceramic in both hands and look out across the yard, the frost on the gravel, the black maple at the edge of the trees, the little shadow of the garden wall.
“It’s right,” I say. “I want it exactly like this. Every day.”
“Then that’s what you’ll get.”
“Oliver.”
“Yes.”
“I’m still angry.”
“I know.”
“I’m going to feel angry for a little while. Maybe a long while.” My voice tightens. “I want to say that first, so you don’t think it’s gone. It isn’t.”
“I wouldn’t want it to be.” He turns, and for the first time since I came out, he looks at me. His eyes are bloodshot and gray and wide open. “It’s yours. You can keep it as long as you like.”
I breathe. I set the mug down on the step between us.
“Here’s what I’ve figured out,” I say. “I thought if someone loved me, they couldn’t do what you did. I thought love and control were opposites. I thought if you were keeping things from me, it meant you didn’t see me.” I look at my hands. “But it’s not that. You saw me. You saw a woman who’d been left, and who was scared, and you wanted so badly not to be one more person who made her run that you made the choice for me.”
“Yes.”
“It was wrong.”
“Yes.”
“It was wrong, Oliver. But it wasn’t…” I search for the word. “It wasn’t leaving. It was the opposite of leaving. You stayed so hard you forgot I had a say.”
He makes a sound in his throat.
“I don’t want that,” I say. “I want to be the one who decides. About the house, and the mail, and my own life. I want you to tell me things. Even when it’s awful. Especially when it’s awful. And I’ll decide what I can handle.” I make myself hold his gaze. “Can you do that?”
“Yes.”
“Don’t say it like a vow. Say it like a fact.”
“I can do that,” Oliver says. “I’ll have to learn. I’ll be bad at it for a while.”
“I’ll tell you when you are.”
“I’m counting on it.”
“There are terms,” I say.
He straightens, as if bracing himself. “Name them.”
“One. I open my own mail. Every piece, every day. If you pick it up from the box, you bring it to the door and you don’t even read the return address.” I take a breath. “I looked it up, by the way. Opening someone else’s mail. It’s a federal crime.”