“Twisted Oak at night is something,” he says at last.
“It is,” I agree. “One of the reasons I bought this place.”
His eyes stay on the water. “Sage said it’s your retreat.”
“He says that like I’m a Victorian widow with delicate nerves.”
That gets a quiet huff from him, closer to a laugh than anything I’ve heard all evening. “He talks about you a lot.”
“Hopefully, with the reverence I deserve.”
“Not even a little,” he says, and when I glance over, there’s dry amusement in his eyes. “Mostly, he says you make excellent coffee and terrible dating decisions.”
I bark out a laugh before I can stop myself. “That sounds like him.”
The smile fades from his mouth, but not from the air between us. He takes a drag, then taps ash neatly over the railing. “Luca’s different with him,” he says finally. “Better.”
I keep my tone light even though I’m listening hard. “That usually happens when somebody loves you well.”
His jaw flexes once. “Yeah.”
There’s enough packed into that one syllable to fill a room.
I don’t turn fully toward him, or try to make it feel like an interview, when I ask, “You close with your brother?”
“Closest thing I’ve got,” he says. Then, after a beat, “We didn’t have the kind of father who made family easy.”
There it is. Not the whole truth, not even close. But enough for a first offering.
I nod slowly. “I know your father’s reputation.”
His mouth tilts without humor. “Most people do.”
“And yet,” I say, taking a sip of cider before the heat leaves it entirely, “you still came up here for Thanksgiving with your brother.”
That makes him look at me. His eyes are bright even in the low light, and there’s something guarded in them that has learned to pass for composure. “He asked,” he says.
“Sounds important.”
“It was.”
We fall back into silence, but it feels less brittle now. He smokes; I sip cider. The stars remain indifferent overhead. Somewhere down by the water, a branch cracks.
You’ve got a hell of a lot on your shoulders, don’t you?
I can see it clearly enough in the set of his spine, the way every answer comes filtered through years of caution, and the look he got when he mentioned his father.
Burden sits all over him. Duty, too. But calling a man out on the weight he’s carrying when he’s only just stepped onto your porch rarely makes him set it down. It just teaches him to hide it better.
So instead I ask, easy as anything, “You always smoke when you can’t sleep?”
He glances down at the cigarette between his fingers. “Something like that.”
“Same,” I say. “Though the cider’s a newer addition. Marginally healthier than whiskey.”
His mouth almost curves again. “Marginally.”
“There you go,” I tell him. “That’s the spirit.”