He shakes his head again, but the smile stays, smaller now, settled into the corners of his mouth. His whole body looks different for those few seconds after laughter; less like a man braced for trial and more like the one he might’ve been if life had offered him softness sooner.
I let myself enjoy the sight of him smiling for one more stolen beat before I look down at my coffee and pretend my pulse hasn’t shifted.
5
JAXON
Charlie’s warmth still clings to my clothes when we get back to the lake house, along with the scent of coffee and sugar. Not to mention the easy comfort of a conversation I didn’t know I needed until I was already in the middle of it.
My pulse is steady for the first time in days. My shoulders are still tight, muscle memory at this point, but not as bad as usual.
Somewhere between the black coffee, the cheesecake, and Aspen looking at me like nothing I’d said was broken or shameful, something inside me got a little quieter.
He glances over, keys still in his hand. “You coming in, or are you planning to sleep in the driveway now that Charlie’s fed you?”
I huff out a laugh before I can help it. “You make that sound like a real possibility.”
“With enough cheesecake in your system, anything’s possible.”
That gets another smile out of me, and I still don’t know how he keeps doing that so easily. I push my door open and step out into the cold, the lake air cutting clean through the cafe’s lingering warmth.
Aspen comes around the hood, coat unbuttoned, one hand shoved in his pocket, his glasses slipping down his nose as we head toward the house.
He looks unfairly good at midnight. That thought comes uninvited and lands hard enough to make me resent it on instinct. Because I’ve noticed before, and tonight only makes it worse.
Aspen Blackwell has one of those faces age was kind to. Dark blond hair touched with gray at the temples. A strong nose, a short beard, and brown eyes that always seem to take in more than he says. Even the glasses do something to me I don’t want to examine too closely, making him look softer and sharper all at once.
I noticed it the first night here. I noticed it on the porch, and when he steadied me out of a panic spiral with nothing but his hands and that calm voice. I noticed it again tonight in Charlie’s, when he made me laugh and looked pleased about it.
I’ve been trying not to think too much about any of that, because overthinking is how you end up with truths you don’t know what to do with.
We make it inside without turning on anything but the small lamp in the entry. I shrug off my jacket and hang it by the door. Aspen disappears into the kitchen for a second and comes back with a bottle of whiskey and two glasses in one hand. He lifts them slightly. “Patio?”
I should say no; I know I should. Midnight whiskey with a man I’ve already been too aware of all evening feels like a bad idea in at least six separate ways.
Instead I hear myself say, “Yeah. Okay.”
He smiles, and nothing in it feels loaded, which somehow makes it worse.
The patio out back is cold enough now that our breath ghosts pale when we sit down. Aspen leaves the patio heater off, says the whiskey will do enough, and hands me a glass before taking the chair beside mine instead of across from me.
The lake stretches dark and still beyond the yard, the moon skimming silver over the water. Somewhere down near the tree line, an owl calls once, then again. The whole valley feels paused.
Aspen leans back and sips his whiskey. “I’d like to point out,” he says after a minute, “that I saved your life tonight.”
I turn to look at him. “At Charlie’s?”
He nods solemnly. “If you’d kept making that face over the cheesecake, Charlie would’ve proposed, and then where would we be?”
I let out a short laugh and shake my head. “You’re ridiculous.”
“And yet,” he says, glancing at me over the rim of his glass, “you got in the car with me voluntarily.”
The words are innocent enough, but the way they land makes heat rise low in my gut. I take a drink of whiskey to buy myself a second, welcoming the burn. “I was lured by dairy and caffeine. Don’t flatter yourself.”
“That’s fair,” he says. “I’ve built an entire personality around artisanal bribes.”
The ease of it catches me off guard all over again. I’m not good at easy; I’m good at polished. But this—this strange, low-lit comfort with a man who somehow keeps seeing past the first layer without stripping me bare—is different. It makes me feel both too visible and oddly calm.