The room was built for gathering, with a deep fireplace that had a mantel that held garland and candles, windows that looked out on the marsh, and those old pine floors that creaked in the most perfect way that meant history rather than neglect.
Isabella had arranged the chairs in a circle, put candles on every surface, and lit a fire that crackled and popped.
It filled the room with the smell of cedar and the particular warmth that only a real fire can produce.
The guest list was very informal: whoever showed up.
A few Ladies’ Club members, Thomas, who, of course, stood by the fireplace with his hands in his pockets, showing the face of a man who would endure anything for Isabella, including singing.
Luella, who didn’t sing but had given them a tray of gingerbread cookies that were arranged with precision, alongside a plate of her brown butter shortbread and a carafe of hot apple cider that she’d spiked with cinnamon sticks and orange peel.
Jack also suspected she might have included a judicious amount of bourbon.
And then there was Eve.
Jack hadn’t known she’d be there.
He should have guessed.
After all, she was part of the island’s fabric and very connected to Isabella and the Ladies’ Club.
But when she walked through the parlor door at seven-fifteen, the sight of her did something to his breathing that he was not prepared to think about.
She was wearing a dark green sweater and her hair was down, which was different.
He’d only ever seen it pulled back, a working ponytail.
Down, it changed her face, softened the angles, made her look less like the owner of a Christmas shop and more like a woman at a party.
And for some reason, that distinction mattered.
She’d seen him immediately.
The inn’s parlor wasn’t big enough that you could miss anyone, and they had exchanged a nod.
That had become their language, just a small thing, an acknowledgement, a You’re here, I see you.
But Nora had no such restraint.
“Eve!” She launched herself across the parlor and attached herself to Eve’s side like a barnacle. “You came. I told Daddy that you were going to come, and he said you might be too busy, but I said no. Eve would always come because she likes singing, and she also likes us.”
“Well, thank you, Nora,” Jack had said, “for that completely accurate summary of our private conversation.”
Eve had smiled, not the professional smile she normally wore at the shop, but something wider, that crinkled the corners of her eyes and showed the small gap between her front teeth.
“She’s a liability.”
Nora laughed at this, interpreting it correctly as a compliment.
Dorothy Prescott led the singing.
She came in with a folder of sheet music that she handled with reverence, like she was a museum curator taking care of the Gutenberg Bible.
The folder, as she explained to anyone who would listen, contained her personal collection of Christmas carols, handwritten arrangements, and printed scores that she’d gathered over forty-seven years as the church organist.
“Now this one,” she said, holding up a yellowed sheet of handwritten notes, “is from 1954. My mother played it at the Christmas Eve service the year Eisenhower was president, and the church roof leaked during Hark the Herald. Oh, the congregation held hymnals over their heads like umbrellas, but they just kept on singing. That is the kind of commitment to music that I expect from every one of you tonight.”
The room laughed, but Dorothy didn’t.