CHAPTER 1
Eve
The first of December always smelled like cinnamon. Well, cinnamon and lots of questionable decisions.
Eve Carlisle stood in the front window of the Silver Bell with one knee pressed into a giant bolt of ivory velvet, a strand of battery-operated twinkle lights she’d gotten at the dollar store clenched between her teeth, trying very hard not to think about the fact that she’d been dreading this exact day since about January 2nd.
She spat out the lights and wiped her mouth with the back of her hand.
“You’re fine,” she muttered to herself. “It’s just a window. Windows aren’t that important. Nobody ever died because of a window. Well, maybe if they fell out of a window, but this one is ground level…”
But it wasn’t just a window.
It was the window.
The one facing Harbor Street and catching the afternoon light, making everything inside it glow like a snow globe. Tourists photographed it and used it as a landmark.
“Turn left at the Christmas shop,” people would say, because Wexley Island only had one. A nine-mile-long island didn’t need two Christmas shops, after all.
Every year, Eve turned this window into something that made people stop on the sidewalk and press their noses to the glass like little children.
Last year, she had designed a Victorian parlor scene with antique ornaments and a porcelain nativity she’d found at an estate sale in Beaufort for a ridiculous price.
The year before that, she’d created a coastal Christmas display with tiny shrimp boats strung in lights, a palmetto tree wearing a Santa hat, and the whole scene dusted in fake snow.
But this year…
She had absolutely no idea what she was doing.
She sat back on her heels and looked at the mess around her.
Boxes of ornaments.
Spools of gold and cranberry ribbon.
The wooden sled she’d bought from a man in Bluffton who swore it was from the 1940s, though it looked suspiciously like something from a Pottery Barn catalog.
Three different kinds of garland because one kind just wasn’t enough, apparently.
A basket of pine cones she’d collected from a forest trail behind her cottage, which had seemed charming at the time but now just looked like… a regular old basket of pine cones.
Still talking to herself like a crazy person, she said, “You need a theme.”
Talking to yourself out loud was perfectly acceptable when you owned a business, lived alone, and just had a cat who never answered back anyway, except to sigh when you were late feeding him. Her cat was very stuck up.
The shop bell jingled behind her.
“Knock, knock.”
Eve didn’t even turn around.
Only one person on the island announced herself by saying “Knock, knock” every time she walked through a door: Isabella Montgomery, the owner of the Wexley Inn.
“I’m not open yet,” Eve called.
“Well, good thing I’m not a customer. I’m just your friend, though you’re making me question that right now.”
Isabella appeared at the edge of the window display, looking completely put together, as always, even though it was only eight-thirty in the morning.