‘I have no idea what you mean,’ I rebutted, trying my best to sound nonchalant.
‘Okay then,’ he said with a grin.
Tobias flipped open his own textbook, which contained a monstrous compilation of medieval scribbles. He began note-taking, and his pen scratched with quick, confident strokes. I tried to return to my reading, but the presence opposite me pulled at me like a magnet. After a minute, he spoke again, softly this time.
‘I didn’t mean the margins thing as an insult, you know. Some people live in the margins because that’s where all the most interesting notes are.’
I blinked. His words lodged in my mind.
Tobias glanced up, caught my expression, and laughed again, disarmingly.
‘Come on then, Orlando. What’s the most interesting thing you’ve read this week?’
I should have ignored him and returned to my research. But something, be it curiosity, recklessness, or simply the unfamiliar sensation of being seen, got the better of me. Against all better sense, I answered him.
And that, though I didn’t yet know it, was the beginning.
‘Orlando?’
‘Hmm? Right. Yes. Hello.’ I rubbed my eyes and glanced at Miss Star, who sat opposite me on the Southeastern train.
‘Sorry to wake you. I just wondered if you wanted a cup of tea? I’m going to go and find the lady with the trolley.’
‘Some refreshment would be splendid.’ I gave her a warm smile. ‘Thank you muchly.’
She stood up and shuffled unsteadily down the carriage. I’d spent the first ten minutes of the journey to London pretending to read. My eyes tracked the sentences, but my mind slipped away every few seconds.
Tobias Hale.
Even the name seemed to produce a faint pressure behind my ribs. One would have hoped that two decades of distance and carefully curated emotional filing would have eradicated such reactions, but apparently not.
We’d met at university: two obsessive young men voluntarily spending evenings in the archives instead of in pubs, deciphering centuries-old letters under bad lighting. Tobias was brilliant then, humming with that quiet, inward intelligence, the sort that didn’t need to announce itself.
In other words, quite unlike mine.
He had gone on to become one of the country’s most prominent forensic document experts. The science of letters had always intrigued him. Most of his time these days was spent working for London’s top barristers, helping to disprove the best theories of the Crown Prosecution Service.
When I say that I’ve kept my distance over the last twenty years, I mean it. It’s just that every so often, his name would appear in the papers, often next to some grateful-looking not-guilty fraudster.
The whole thing is rather difficult for me to think about, let alone articulate. In the case of Tobias, I admired him long before I allowed myself to … appreciate him romantically. Good Lord. Even now, I struggle with the vocabulary of it. Words imply clarity, and that was something we never quite managed.
Technically, we spent three years ‘together’, as most would term it.
To me, though, ‘together’ feels too imprecise a term for something so intricate. I think we understood each other intellectually better than emotionally, which, come to think of it, may have been the problem. Or one of them. We cared deeply about one another, but caring and communicating are not synonyms, and we were both far better at the former.
The countryside blurred past the window, and I found myself tracing the condensation on the glass with my fingertip. If our dalliance had ended for any single, clean reason, I might have felt more justified in contacting him years earlier. But life rarely offers clean reasons.
Instead, there had been that dark period. The one I don’t talk about.
The accident.
The impossible phone call.
The sudden absence of my mother’s voice, which I hadn’t yet realised formed a kind of internal scaffolding in me. Vivienne Forbes had died in a tragic car crash when I was in the middle of my studies at Oxford.
Grief rearranged everything. It made the world unfamiliar and made me unfamiliar to myself. Tobias tried. He showed up with books, brought food I didn’t eat, sat beside me in silence because he didn’t know what to say. The real tragedy is that if Tobias had succeeded in drawing me out of my shell at university, my mother’s death sent me back in deeper than I had ever been before. I folded in on myself, combusted, collapsed. Tobias kept reaching; I kept evaporating. Eventually we both stopped pretending it was temporary.
I simply didn’t know how to be a person then, let alone someone else’s. And by the time I was ready to learn again, the moment had passed.