‘I wonder whether Alex dropping this essay was deliberate,’ Star pondered. ‘Did he want us all to eventually know the notes to Philip were from him?’
Tobias scratched his head. ‘Why would he want us to know that?’
‘Perhaps he wanted to show us how clever he was,’ I posited. ‘Hmm.’ I placed my hands behind my back and strode across the bookshop, because if one is going to be alarmed, one may as well own the room. ‘A teenager named Alex Morcant, knowing his own family possessed a first edition copy of A Christmas Carol, directed you, Philip Whitehead, to me, Orlando Forbes, so that I might go and buy it.’
There seemed to be general agreement from the room, though no one appeared especially comforted by it.
‘But for what purpose? And why would he request my involvement? He could have saved two years of tail-chasing by admitting his family possessed the very copy you were seeking!’
‘Very unusual behaviour,’ whispered Whitehead.
‘No,’ Star said, after a moment’s thought. ‘The unusual behaviour is writing to you as two people, one encouraging you to proceed, the other threatening you if you did.’
‘Unless,’ Tobias said slowly, his attention returning to the letters, ‘that contradiction was the point.’
We all looked at him. He picked up the encouraging letter and held it beneath the light. ‘He wanted you to act,’ he said to Whitehead. ‘But quietly. He wanted the book found, but not announced. He wanted Orlando involved, but not forewarned. He wanted to set the search in motion but control how much everyone knew.’
I looked hard at our Christmas Eve visitor, trying to reconcile the man before me with the evasive stranger who first entered my shop. ‘If you don’t mind me saying so, Mr Whitehead, you have grown in confidence considerably this year. You’re singing like the proverbial canary. Previously, all I’ve had out of you are grunts.’
‘Well,’ he said, slightly embarrassed, shifting beneath my gaze, ‘I suppose that’s because the threats have stopped.’
I raised an eyebrow. ‘When?’
He rubbed his eyes, searching his memory. ‘I suppose about, uh … six months ago?’
‘In other words,’ I said slowly, as the dates arranged themselves in my mind, ‘exactly when I bought the book from the Morcant family.’
‘So Alex stopped sending notes as soon as the sale had gone through,’ confirmed Tobias. ‘Once it was in your possession, Orlando, he had achieved his goal, it seems.’
I remembered Alex phoning his father at Cae Glas after the sale, to confirm who had purchased the book. At the time, it had seemed no more than a harmless call. Now it felt like something else entirely.
This was a boy who had placed us all exactly where he wanted us.
Whitehead spoke next.
‘But why go to all this trouble? What does a boy care about Eliza Wetherill?’
Star looked towards the window. ‘Perhaps Eliza was never the end of it,’ she said very quietly.
The clock behind the counter struck six.
One chime.
Then another.
Outside, someone laughed in the rain, bright and distant. Inside, none of us moved.
The first edition of A Christmas Carol lay open beneath the lamp. On the counter beside it, Alex Morcant’s essay rested between the letters he had written in two different hands.
For two years we had thought Fred Topper was the mystery.
Now I understood.
He had only been the messenger.
Somewhere, Alexander Morcant had begun this story long before any of us knew we were in it. And he had stopped sending warnings only when the book was finally where he wanted it to be.
With us.