I’m not my brothers.
I’m the calm, cool, collected Masterson who doesn’t let anything faze me, even when it’s as fucked up as this.
I can’t believe I was considering marrying this girl.
I pull out my phone four different times to call her, but each time I hear her mother’s voice in my head from a conversation I overheard at dinner six months ago.
“Obviously, Seven’s just a first-love situation. Sasha deserves a future with someone who can provide her with security and respectability. A basic web search on their family can tell you he’s not the right fit. Imagine introducing him to Nana.”
The old Seven, the one who existed this morning, would’ve said fuck that noise and driven straight to Boston. He would’ve demanded that she look me in the eye and tell me she didn’t love me anymore.
But this Seven, the one sitting in a gutted apartment holding a Dear John letter, finally understands the truth her parents have been holding onto all along.
I wasn’t worth fighting her family for.
If I had been, she would’ve done it herself, and she wouldn’t be in Boston instead of in bed with me.
I’m not going to lie. This shit hurts.
I would’ve rather she cheated on me. Another dude with a dick is something I can fight. Her parents’ bad opinion is a much harder obstacle.
I open my laptop and start systematically deleting every photo of us together. Each click feels like another nail in the coffin of what I thought was going to be my forever.
When I finish, I send a text to my two brothers.
Me: Looking to get fucked up tonight. Sasha and I are over. Who’s down?
If there’s one thing growing up a Masterson has taught me, it’s that we don’t show weakness, at least not for long.
I close my laptop, grab my wallet and some smoke, and walk out of the place that has been the center of many good laughs and endless nights with the woman I thought was the love of my life.
I decide to leave every memory there and never revisit them.
I don’t look back.
Not even once.
Present Day
I jerk back to reality, my coffee stone cold in my hands as the memory releases its stranglehold on my chest.
All these years later, I can still smell that damn vanilla candle. I can still feel the phantom ache of a twenty-year-old’s shattered heart.
My phone buzzes with another notification. It’s probably Mom asking about Sunday dinner, Bronx sending me some dumb-ass meme, or literally anyone other than the one person I’ve spent all this time alternately hoping to hear from and dreading contact with.
I’ve spent most of the years since sleeping with nameless, almost faceless women and assuring my family that I haven’t given Sasha a moment’s thought since she walked out of my life.
But have I been lying to them?
And to myself?
Because when I read Kevin’s email and saw her name, I was twenty years old again, standing in a room where we had made love countless times and learning the hard lesson that sometimes love isn’t enough.
Love is for other people.
Not me.
I spend the next ninety minutes distracting myself with my daily work call with Stella and then a quick HIIT workout. Even an endorphin rush can’t clear my mind of her.