I'm telling you because I think you understood love differently.
I don't know enough about the house where you grew up to tell you what happened there. I only know that you seemed to expect every gift to become a debt, every kindness to create an obligation, and every expression of love for Connor to become a claim against him.
You were wrong about us. Our love did not come with a bill.
However, we also misunderstood something. We believed that since what we considered love felt genuine to us, it would also feel like love to you.
Before Connor was born, Sylvia and I lost a baby. We always believed the baby was a girl. When you entered our lives, some of the love Sylvia had carried for that daughter turned toward you. Some of mine did too. We saw the possibility of loving you as the daughter we never had.
I understand now that this may have felt like a role assigned to you without your consent. You were not responsible for filling a void you did not create. We should have asked what kind of relationship you wanted instead of assuming we knew.
That part belongs to us.
But our failure to love you in a way you could receive it does not make what happened afterward harmless.
You hurt Sylvia. You allowed private matters to become public and false claims to become part of an official record. You turned messages sent to our son into evidence against us. You and Connor kept Reed beyond our reach.
Those were choices. I will not call them misunderstandings to make the truth easier to accept.
I eventually understood that fear may have underpinned some of those choices. That understanding did not make me less angry. It made my anger more accurate. I could feel sorry for whatever taught you to see love as a threat and still hold you responsible for what you did with that fear.
Both are possible.
I don't know whether any of this helps. But I wanted the record to contain the whole truth:
We loved you imperfectly.
We never wanted to take Connor from you.
You hurt us.
And I am still sorry for you, for us, and for the life all of us might have shared if we had understood the right things before it was too late.
Take care of my son.
Take care of yourself.
Those aren't the same instructions.
They're both important.
Walt
I put the pages down.
Somewhere in the last paragraph, the story I have been telling for thirty years shifted its weight—the way a house does, once, quietly, when something under it lets go.
The last pages say “Reed.”
My son’s name, in my mother’s hand.
The floor goes out from under me.
Reed—
I have called you my grandson in my heart since the day I learned you existed. I don’t know whether that word will feel true to you. You never had the chance to call me anything.
The name I wanted was GiGi.