I think about Connor.
Not the way I usually think about Connor on this dock, which is with the specific weight of the missing and the missing's daily renewal. I think about what he doesn’t know. What we never told him. Not because we were ashamed of it, but because we wanted better for him than the knowledge of it—and now I’m sitting here at five in the morning, wondering if that was the right call.
He doesn’t know about the winter I drove a delivery truck.
He was six years old. The engineering work dried up in November—a contract canceled, another delayed, the specific confluence of bad timing that happens in any profession but hits harder when you’re still building the cushion meant to absorb it. I didn’t tell Sylvia how bad it was until February, when it was over. I took the truck job in December through a guy I knew from construction, six days a week, from four in the morning until noon. I was home by the time Connor woke up. Sylvia thought I was doing supplemental consulting. I wasn’t. I was driving a truck.
I told her in February when the contract came back.
She cried. Not because I’d done it—because I’d done it alone. We had our version of the argument. I said I didn’t want her to worry. She said she’d rather worry with me than not know. I said that was easy to say after the fact. She said that was beside the point. We were both right, and we both knew it, and eventually we moved on.
Connor never knew. He just knew that Christmas was a little leaner than usual that year and that I was tired a lot in January.
He is unaware of the years before his time—the apartment on Denning Street, the versatile kitchen table, and the heater that only worked sporadically. He doesn’t realize how young we truly were—not just in age but in experience, making decisions with incomplete information and hoping the foundation would hold long enough to figure everything out. He also doesn’t know about the baby we lost before him. We never shared that with him. Sylvia once wanted to tell him when he was in his twenties and going through his own struggles, believing it might help him see that loss can be endured. I told her to let him discover it himself through his life. I now think I was wrong, and perhaps it no longer matters.
He’s unaware of the arguments, the fault line we spent ten years navigating. Growing up, he saw his parents connect effortlessly, as reaching each other seemed natural by the time he observed it. He never saw us learn it. He only saw the outcome.
I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately, about the specific consequence of giving a child a life without visible struggle. You do it because you love them. You do it because you remember the weight of watching your own parents struggle, and you don’t want to pass that weight down. You do it because that’s the whole point—each generation builds what the next one stands on, and the building is the labor, and the labor doesn’t have to be visible to be real.
But.
A child who has never seen the cost doesn’t know there is one. A child who grows up on solid ground doesn’t know what it took to make it solid. He looks at the foundation, and he thinks: this is just how ground works. He doesn’t think, “Someone poured this. Someone made decisions in the dark and got up before dawn and drove a truck for three months and sat on a bathroom floor and kept going.”
Connor is thirty-three years old, and he has never, as far as I know, driven a delivery truck.
He has a doctorate in physics. He has a house in Knoxville. He has a salary that makes what I made in my best year look like the winter with the truck. He has all of this because we poured it under him so he could stand on it.
He doesn’t know we poured it.
I don’t say this with bitterness. I want to be clear about that. He was a child. Children aren’t supposed to know. The whole point is that they don’t—that they get to live on the surface of the thing without seeing the pilings beneath. That’s what parents are for. That’s what we signed up for.
But I wonder.
I wonder if a person who has never seen love struggle can recognize love when it’s struggling. I wonder if a person who has only ever known what a solid foundation feels like can be taught to mistake it for something dangerous. I wonder if we loved him so thoroughly, so visibly, so loudly that it became something someone could point to and call excessive. If the very completeness of it—the centerpieces, the drives, the daily I love you, the dissertation bound in a cover with his name on it—looked, through a different vocabulary, like something other than what it was.
I don’t know the answer to this.
The dock doesn’t know either. The lake doesn’t. The light coming up over the ridge is the same light it’s always been, and it doesn’t have any answers.
I just know we gave him everything we had, even the things we had to make from nothing. He grew up not knowing about the nothing. Now he’s thirty-three years old, somewhere in Knoxville with my grandson and a woman who taught him a different language for love. I am on this dock at five in the morning, trying to figure out where the math went wrong.
I reach over and put my hand over hers on the arm of the chair. She turns her palm up.
The lake keeps being the lake.
That’s always been enough
CHAPTER 27
Every Day
Sylvia
Ifind it on a Thursday afternoon in June, in the drawer of the nightstand on my side of the bed.
A photograph. I don’t remember putting it there, but I must have moved it from somewhere else and set it here so I could stop looking at it without having to throw it away. Connor, at seventeen, in his baseball uniform, holding a trophy to his chest with both hands, the way children hold things they’ve earned and aren’t quite sure they deserve yet. He’s looking at the camera with the expression he always wore when he was trying not to grin and failing—the expression that was pure him, the one I could pick out across a field in a crowd of two hundred people.
I sit on the edge of the bed, and I hold it.