Page List

Font Size:

“I keep thinking,” she says, “that if I had known sooner, I could have stopped something.”

“That wasn’t yours to stop.”

“You don’t know that.”

“No. But I know whose choice it was.”

She is quiet.

I look out at the water. “You could have known every message the day it was sent and still not controlled what Gloria chose to do with it. You could have called Connor. You could have called Claudia. You could have driven over there. You could have stood in Gloria’s living room and said every true thing in the English language, and it still would not have made her choose you if choosing you cost her the position she wanted.”

Sylvia’s breath catches once. Not a sob. Just a catch.

“She should have chosen me,” she says.

“I know.”

“She should have told me.”

“The minute she knew.”

“She should have protected me.”

“She should have been the one person you never needed protection from.”

“She should have wanted me there.”

I close my eyes for a moment.

“You were her daughter, Syl. She should have refused to have that room without you in it.”

That is the simplest indictment. Not the messages. Not the secrecy. Not even Reed, though Reed is the blade of it. The mother should have wanted her daughter there. She should have looked at a room where her daughter was absent and felt that absence as wrong. She should have felt it in her body. She should have said, No. Not like this. Not without Sylvia. Not if this costs my daughter.

Instead, she planned.

Instead, she hosted.

Instead, she kept the secret and called it whatever she needed to call it so she could sleep.

Sylvia lifts her head and wipes beneath one eye with the heel of her hand, annoyed by the tear more than anything else. That is very Sylvia. She can be devastated and still irritated by the logistics of crying.

“I don’t want to become her,” she says.

“You aren’t.”

“You can’t know that.”

“I can.”

“How?”

“Because you’re asking the question. Gloria never did.”

She absorbs that. Then she looks back at the lake.

I think again of Connor. Of the question he has not yet asked. What am I not seeing? What is missing from the story I have accepted? Who benefits from my certainty? Who is absent from the room, and why?

If he ever asks it—truly asks it—everything will begin to move. If he doesn’t, the structure holds.


Novels you may like ...