True Colors
Sylvia
It happens in increments.
That’s what I want to say to someone someday, when I can talk about this without the words going sideways. It didn’t happen all at once. There was no moment when I understood that certain people in this town had quietly decided, without consulting me, to put some distance between themselves and whatever Claudia’s posts described. It arrived the way winter arrives in the mountains—not as an event but as a cumulative condition, one degree at a time, until one morning you look at the thermometer and realize the season has changed and you weren’t watching closely enough to catch the exact moment.
Beth Gallagher, whom I have known for twenty years and whose daughter was in three of my English classes, stopped texting in December. We have been the kind of friends who text funny things that happened, questions about the farmers’ market hours, and recipes shared without preamble. The texts stopped. When I run into her at the market in January, she is warm—perfectly warm, the warmth of someone who is being careful—and she asks about my adjunct course and how Walt is getting along, and she doesn’t ask about Connor, which everyone eventually stops asking about, except that the way she doesn’t ask is different from the way Ruthanne doesn’t ask. Ruthanne doesn’t ask because she already knows and is giving me space to say it when I’m ready. Beth doesn’t ask because she’s already received a version of the answer she found more convenient.
I think about this in the car on the way home from the market. Then I put it in the place where I put things I can’t do anything about yet, and I drive home.
On the shoreline path, there’s a man named Greg Purcell whom I’ve passed every morning for four years. We’ve never been friends, exactly, but we’ve become what people become when they share a daily route—familiar, nodding, occasionally stopping for the kind of conversation that’s more about weather and local events than anything personal. In January, he starts taking a different section of the path. I notice this on the third morning in a row. I tell myself he’s varying his route. I stop telling myself this on the fifth morning.
Carol is my closest friend of fifteen years, the one who materializes on the shoreline path on the mornings I'm not okay and says the wrong thing in entirely the right spirit, something I have always loved about her.
She sees the posts. I know she does because the phone rings on a Tuesday evening, and it's Carol.
"I've been reading some of Claudia's posts," she says, carefully, the way Carol does when she's worried about the landing. "And I just want to ask." She pauses. The pause is the kind that hopes the question won't have to be finished. Then she finishes it anyway. "Is there anything to any of it?"
I'm quiet long enough that she understands she's said something that can't be unsaid.
“I’m sorry,” she says quickly. “I shouldn’t have—I just don’t know her. And you’re my friend. I wanted to ask you directly instead of assuming.”
"No," I say. "There's nothing to it."
I understand why she asked. I understand the logic—that asking directly is better than assuming, that she was trying to be fair, and that she loves me and wanted to give me the chance to answer. I understand all of this. I also understand that a woman who has known me for fifteen years, who walked beside me during the years I raised Connor and through the years of this estrangement, looked at a stranger’s social media posts and found herself uncertain enough to ask.
"I knew that," she says. "I knew that, Sylvia."
We chat for a few more minutes, ending the call on a warm note. We stay friends, as I believe we always will—a friendship maintained despite discovering, perhaps unintentionally, the boundaries of our connection. Both of us are aware of this, and we manage it because our history is too deep to undo over a single question. Yet something has subtly and permanently changed between who Carol was before she asked and who she is afterward.
As my friend of fifteen years, I shouldn’t have had to explain that there was nothing to it. Those should’ve been her first words to me.
I don’t tell Walt about Carol’s call. He’s carrying enough.
The Friday evening crowd at Lakeview Wine in March is thinner than in December. Late winter is always thin, the doldrums, the lake people long gone, and the year-rounders keeping to their own hearths. I go for a glass of wine on the last Friday of the month because I need to be somewhere that isn’t the house. Sasha is behind the bar, pouring my wine, and we talk about the next farmers’ market season and whether the Hendersons are going to sell their stand to their daughter or just close it. It’s a good conversation, the kind that asks nothing of me.
Then Pam and Ted Merritt come in.
Pam and Ted have lived in Calder’s Cove for twelve years. They are lake people who became year-rounders, the third category, the ones who stayed. Pam taught art at the high school for seven years before retiring. I taught down the hall from her for five of those years. We have been the kind of colleagues who like each other—not intimate, not in and out of each other’s houses, but genuinely warm, the kind of warmth that builds over years of shared hallways, faculty meetings, and the camaraderie of teachers who are all, always, slightly exhausted.
She sees me at the bar. Something crosses her face quickly, gone before I could name it if I tried, a kind of recalibration. She smiles. It’s not cold. It’s not the smile of someone who dislikes me. It’s the smile of someone who has read something and is not yet sure what to do with it. Her not-sureness is visible to me because I have been a teacher for thirty years, and I know what uncertainty looks like on a face when it’s trying to be invisible.
They take a table in the back. They don’t come to say hello.
Sasha remains silent, refilling my glass at the perfect moment and steering the conversation back to the farmers’ market. I love her for it, finish my wine, and head home.
I walk in to find Walt at the table, where he always is in the evening, with the newspaper, the coffee, and the posture of a man who has been waiting without wanting to appear to do so. He looks up when I come in.
“How was it?”
“Fine,” I say.
He gazes at me for a moment. He knows everything. He always does. Yet he doesn’t ask, and I don’t volunteer answers, because we’ve learned over these months that some things don’t improve when spoken aloud. One such thing is the gradual distancing of people who used to smile at me as if they knew me.
I hang up my coat. I make a cup of tea I don’t particularly want. I sit across from him at the table.
“Pam Merritt was at Lakeview,” I say.