“I don’t know.” Grace rubbed a hand over her eyes. “Maybe.” When she looked up at him again, she seemed embarrassed to have admitted that out loud. “Am I losing my mind?”
She wouldn’t be the first person on this island to experience a break from reality, Aidan thought. But he was pretty sure Grace’s sanity was still intact. He was actually impressed with how open-minded she was being. And he couldn’t help admiring the fact that she’d decided to drop everything, including her job, to immerse herself in this search the moment she’d gotten her first clue. “No,” he said finally. “I don’t think you’re losing your mind.”
Relieved that he wasn’t going to judge her, she sat back and watched the last wisps of fog float away. The water lapped at the rocks at their feet. A few gulls rode the soft breezes overhead. “Glenna thinks I should stop searching.”
“Why?”
“She said when a woman runs away from her husband, she doesn’t want to be found.”
That had been true in Tara’s case, Aidan thought. But not every woman who ran away from her husband was afraid for her life. And how did Glenna know, for sure, that Grace’s mother had run away? She could have been taken or killed or any number of other possibilities. “Do you remember your parents fighting a lot when you were a kid?”
“No,” Grace said. “That’s what’s so strange about all this. I never saw them argue. From what I could tell, they seemed happy together. But even if they weren’t, why would she run away? Why wouldn’t she just ask for a divorce?”
That, Aidan thought, was a question he didn’t have an answer to. And he imagined it was one that had haunted Grace for most of her life. “Did the police ever look at your father as a person of interest?”
Grace nodded. “In the weeks after her disappearance, every police officer, detective, and social worker asked my brother and me the same questions whenever they got us alone. Did our parents fight a lot? Did our mother ever seem afraid? Had we ever seen bruises on her? Did our father have a temper? Did he yell at her or at us? Had he ever hit us?”
Aidan pulled her hand into his lap and covered it with both of his. He’d dealt with his share of detectives and social workers after his parents had been killed, but there’d never been a question about how they had died or who had been responsible. Grace, on the other hand, didn’t even know who to blame.
“They never said the words outright,” she continued, “but I knew what they were implying. That if he hadn’t killed her, he’d probably abused her.”
“You don’t think that was the case, though?”
“No,” she said adamantly.
Then it must not be, Aidan thought. Grace was one of the most perceptive people he’d ever met. If she didn’t think her father had anything to do with her mother’s disappearance, then something else must have happened. And she would never be able to put this behind her until she found out the truth. Who was Glenna to tell her to stop? “What’s your next move?”
She looked up at him. “You think I should keep searching?”
“I do,” Aidan said. If someone told him that his mother was alive, he would go to the ends of the earth to find her. Unfortunately, he couldn’t tell Grace that, because as far as she knew, his mother was alive.
“Well,” Grace said, “I still need to figure out what the rest of the people on this island are hiding.”
Aidan nodded slowly. He wasn’t going to pretend that they weren’t hiding something anymore. He’d watched Grace catch Liam in a blatant lie the night before, and he knew she suspected that Tara had been lying as well. But he would need to tread carefully. “You think it has something to do with your mother?”
“I don’t know. But right now, it’s all I have to go on. And I’m not leaving until I figure it out.”
Conflicted, Aidan looked out at the water. He knew what the islanders were hiding, and it had nothing to do with her mother. As much as he wanted to spend the next few weeks with her, he also didn’t want to waste her time. He knew how much this trip must be costing her, not just financially, but emotionally. If he told her the truth, she could leave on the next ferry and continue her search.
But he couldn’t do that, could he? Not when he’d given Tara his word. Besides, this wasn’t his secret to tell.
Looking back at Grace, he wondered if there was a way he could help her without betraying Tara’s trust. “You said you came here to research the legends because you thought you might find another clue hidden in one of them?”
Grace nodded.
“The man I’m renting my cottage from has a library full of myths, legends, and fairy tales. I haven’t read any of them yet, but he said I could borrow one at any time.” Aidan nodded back toward the path that had brought him here. “Want to have a look?”
FIFTEEN
It was Grace’s second time on the farm in two days. She took in the rolling green hills that dipped down to the sea, the winding stone walls that divided the land into pastures, and the curious ponies that glanced up as they passed. A sheepdog stood guard outside a shed where an elderly man was mucking out a stall. She could hear the gentle roll of the ocean all around them, and as they made their way closer, the soft rustle of hay beneath the farmer’s pitchfork.
Remembering the strange scene she’d stumbled into the day before, her gaze shifted to the stretch of white sand that bordered the east side of the island. She wondered if Brigid had gone to another beach to gather shells today, or if she’d gotten over whatever had compelled her to gather them in the first place. She had a feeling there was more to Brigid’s story than any of the islanders had been letting on. Maybe she’d be able to get to the bottom of that now that she and Aidan were spending the day together.
She stole a glance at the man beside her. This wasn’t exactly the day she’d had planned. She’d woken up this morning resolved to avoid him. But how could she decline his offer to help after the kindness he’d shown her earlier? She’d expected him to say she was crazy for trying to find her mother after all these years, even more so for researching fairy tales for clues about what might have happened to her.
Instead, he’d offered to help her with her search.
Was it just an excuse to spend time with her? Or did he genuinely want to help her? Her instincts were telling her that his motives were genuine. But she didn’t know if she could trust her instincts around him anymore. Any warning signals that might have been trying to protect her had short-circuited the moment his mouth had met hers the night before. The only thing her body seemed to want when she was anywhere near him was to be fused to his.