I swallow nausea. My hands fall into my lap. I can’t look at her. “How did you know you wanted to be with Donny?” I rasp.
“I don’t know . . . It was just right, with him. He loves me, and I love him. Why are you asking me this?”
“Was he your first love?” I stare hard at my fingernails.
Esther tips her body until she’s practically lying with her head in my lap. “Olivia?” A smile spreads across her face.
I bite my lip.
She lies on her back, her head still cradled on my thighs. My limbs become wood. “Well,” she says slowly, “I didn’t really do a lot of dating. Neither have you, really.” She peeks up at me.
I tear away my gaze, staring down at the corduroy couch. I drag my nails up and down the fabric. The sensation of it under my nails is a soothing distraction.
“I just woke up one day and knew I loved Donny. And it was terrifying, don’t get me wrong. He’s twenty-six years older than me. And he’s a man. He could be using me. But have you seen him with the girls? He loves them like they’re his own little sisters. You can’t fake that.” She squares me with a look. “You and me are different people,” she continues. “My heart was soft and open because of my grandparents, because of the girls. It was easy for him to get in. I used to dream that a dark knight would ride in and save me,” she says with a little smile.
“You saved yourself,” I point out.
“So did you. But who’s been right by your side?”
I try to push it away, but there’s too much already in there. “Fuck,” I whisper.
She snickers. “It isn’t the worst thing, you know.”
I massage my temples with my knuckles. “Fuck.”
Sitting up, she pats my leg. “You’ll get used to it.”
I gape at her. “It doesn’t go away?”
“Girl, I’m about two seconds away from laughing at you. You can’t control who you—“
I hold up a hand. “Uh-uh. It’s just strong feelings because of his magic dick.”
“Sure.” She stands from the couch. “There’s micellar water in the bathroom, and more mascara. Get yourself cleaned up. I need to go grocery shopping, and you’re coming with.”
I make an emo face at her. “What, you don’t like my makeup?”
“I’ll buy you a G’s burger.”
I stand in a hurry. “I’m gonna need your face wash, too.”
“Mi casa es su casa, but hurry up. I want to get back here in time for General Hospital.”
“Jesus, Esther. The Donny feelings are ruining you,” I call over my shoulder on my way to the bathroom.
She scoffs. “I was already a hopeless romantic. I’ll have you know, my GH obsession is Abuela’s fault.”
I arrange the supplies on the counter. “Next you’re gonna tell me you guys are trying to get pregnant.”
In answer, she says nothing. I scrub at the mascara on my cheeks and try not to think about a tiny baby in a River Reapers onesie.