I glance up at her. The emotions swimming in her eyes must mirror mine. I swallow hard. "It’s not okay," I force out. "Because it wasn’t an accident."
She bites her lip. "You did what you had to do."
"I thought I was doing it for you." Blinking, I see a flash of the past, Lucy huddled in the corner of the kitchen, those green eyes locked on mine. Her face pale, small body shaking in shock. And me, towering over my father’s lifeless body, his blood still hot and wet on my hands. I hadn’t even hesitated. There was no question. "I liked it, Luce. I was high on it." Even though I’m looking at the adult sitting next to me, all I can see is the little girl in the kitchen with the monster standing in front of her. "And I hurt you," I finish, lifting the cigarette to my lips with shaking fingers.
She scoffs. "You didn’t hurt me. I was scared. And I’d never seen anything . . . like that before." She squeezes my hand again. "Cliff, you saved me. He would’ve done it again and again. And no one else was going to stop him. I sure as fuck couldn’t." Green eyes tug me back into the present, back from the edge.
"I shoved you into that cabinet," I say between gritted teeth. "If the cops hadn’t come—"
Her gaze holds me. "You didn’t shove me. You were trying to keep me safe from him." She shakes her head. "Jesus, Cliff. Why are you making yourself out to be the bad guy? I was there, too. And I know you. I know what I saw."
I don’t know why I expected her to understand. She can’t possibly feel what I do. Only when you become the monster do you understand the power that comes with taking a life. It’s still there, whispering to me.
"It was so easy." I finish the cigarette, flicking it out the window. "He didn’t even beg, didn’t even apologize. Sometimes I wonder if I still would’ve done it."
"There’s no point in torturing yourself," Lucy says. "What’s done is done. All you can do is continue being a good man. Because you are, Cliff. You doubt yourself, but I’ve never doubted who you are. You’re not the bad guy in this story."
This conversation is just depressing. I thought Lucy was the only person in the world who understands me, but she doesn’t know me at all. It’s just another wedge between us.
I shift the car into drive. "Thanks, Luce." One corner of my mouth lifts in what I hope is a convincing smile. "All right, kid. Teach me how to drive."
We spend the next hour brushing me up on the basics. It’s muscle memory, really, because soon I’m zipping around the empty lot. Parallel parking is the only thing I can’t do, but I never nailed it as a teenager, either. Lucy shows me a trick for backing into spaces, assuring me that I’ll definitely pass my driver’s license test.
"As long as they forget to have you parallel park," she says.
"Thanks for the vote of confidence."
"Just being honest." She pats my shoulder. "All right, take us home."
It’s not the same as riding a hog, but I handle the car well enough, bringing us back to Lucy’s condo in one piece. Part of me wonders if it’s even worth getting a driver’s license. All I want to do is ride. But Lucy and even most of my new brothers agree that if I’m going to go legit, I might as well get both.
"That was smooth," Lucy compliments me as we pull into her driveway. "So where are you taking Livvie tonight?"
I grunt. "Just work. Then maybe somewhere after. I don’t know." I peek at her out of the corner of one eye. "Where should I take her?"
She covers a smile with her hand. "That late at night?" She lifts an eyebrow at me.
I slump back in my seat. "Straight home, I guess."
"Good boy." Planting a quick kiss on my cheek, she unbuckles her seatbelt. "Behave, kids." She slides out and waves goodbye, then disappears inside.
I head to Olivia’s, 99.1 PLR’s broadcast of songs I grew up with cranking out of the speakers as I navigate the back roads to avoid being pulled over. It’s a bit unnerving, knowing that music from my childhood is now considered classic rock. The world moved on while I was inside.
I pull up in front of her apartment, the engine idling while I try to decide whether to get out and knock on the door. It would be the gentlemanly thing to do, but I don’t know whether we’re dating. I don’t know what we’re doing at all.
I get out anyway and jog up to the front door. A tiny meow greets me from the other side, giving me away. I knock and then back off a couple steps. I don’t want to look too eager.
The door swings open a crack. A Puerto Rican woman wearing nothing but a bathrobe peers out at me. She’s about Olivia’s age, and the look on her face is suspicious at best. "Who the fuck are you?"
I open my mouth to answer, but Olivia marches up behind the other woman.
"It’s just Cliff," she says, grinning at me.
Her roommate opens the door all the way, scowling the whole time, but she moves aside so I can come in.
Olivia hugs me with one arm, an orange furball tucked into the crook of her other arm. She lifts a hand toward her roommate. “This is Esther."
I nod at Esther. "Nice to meet you."