The dryness of her throat made speech impossible, so she slid her hands up his arms and gripped his biceps as their mouths met. Luckily he didn’t seem to expect a response.
Of course she loved doing this with him. Loved him, period. Other than Matt, she’d never loved another man.
Never would.
She drew her knees as close to her chest as possible, heaving out a breath as her hard nipples rubbed against her skin. He reached up and flicked the hard tips, his gaze caressing hers with the same intensity as his cock plunged into her pussy.
God, she was so wet. She’d been wet for him for years. If she hadn’t been so good at living in denial, she would’ve had to face up to that a long time ago.
“Oh, Tristan.” The plea caused her cheeks to flood with heat. But she didn’t let it stop her. “I’m going to come,” she said, clenching around his thick cock until he released a long, needy groan. “Come with me.”
Even as a relative newcomer to this whole game, she knew he was close. He sank deep, his balls tight and firm when they slapped her ass. His strokes quickened, becoming more frantic. Sweat dotted his brow, and his muscles bulged as he fisted his hands in the pillows beside her head.
“Can’t. Have to…” He couldn’t seem to form words, and she loved that she destroyed his control.
His body battered hers, his face tightening as he reached his peak before she did. He didn’t make a sound, but he shuddered so hard she was afraid he’d break in two. Then he was thrusting deeper, so deep she couldn’t restrain a cry as her inner walls contracted over and over again.
The residual tremors from her climax had barely subsided when he shifted their positions, scooping her up and rolling over until she was on top of him. Still inside her, he flexed his semihard length, making her whimper.
“See what you do to me?” He thumbed her hair out of her eyes. “One orgasm isn’t nearly enough.”
She grinned. “For me either. Multiples always seem to work best when you and Matt are around.”
He rubbed her damp arm, not meeting her eyes. “Move back in, Caity. It’s not the same without you.”
She waited until she could be certain her voice wouldn’t shake. “Technically I never really left. I just slept over at my mom’s since Sunday. All my stuff’s still here.”
“All your stuff isn’t you.”
“No.” She laid her head on his chest, closing her eyes. “What if I asked you to choose me over Matt?”
His hand stilled.
“You couldn’t, could you?” she asked quietly, understanding completely.
“No. Just like you can’t choose me over him.”
“We’ve always been a trio.”
“Glad you’re finally acknowledging that, Caity Bait.”
Somehow his using that nickname when they were naked in his bed added a layer of the forbidden to what had always been a fond, if somewhat embarrassing, memory.
With a long sigh, she wiggled away until he slid out of her body. Once he’d disposed of the condom, he returned, snuggling her into his tight embrace.
“You’re really not worried what anyone will say, are you?” she asked, drawing patterns on his shoulder with the edge of her fingernail.
“About us? No. I think most people will be jealous.”
She snorted at that. “Some people will probably think we’re immoral.”
“Those people aren’t us.” Tristan tipped her chin until their gazes were level. “Want to run away? Start over someplace new? That way we wouldn’t run into people we know every day. Eventually we could come out to our families, on our own timetable.”
Come out. She wet her lips. He made it all sound so easy. “We have a business here. A very successful one.”
“Ask me which is more important to me.” The expression he wore answered the question so succinctly she didn’t bother.
“Tell me this,” he said after a moment. “If you weren’t worried what people would say, your family in particular, would you give us a try? All three of us?”