“All in due time,” she said, wary once again. As curious as she was—and as much as she’d enjoyed everything thus far—she was still anxious when she allowed herself to think about being with both men simultaneously.
“We also don’t know what it’s like to go out with you,” Matt said, crawling back into bed.
“That’s completely untrue,” she said. “We’ve gone out a million times.”
“Not just going out. A date.”
“With both of you? I can’t do that,” she said, though she knew she was circling back to the same fight they’d had earlier. But she’d be damned if they operated under any illusions.
Monday they’d go back to work. Friday she’d head home to spend Christmas Eve with her family while Tristan and Matt headed to Tristan’s house. Matt’s mom lived in Idaho, and some years they didn’t spend the holiday together, though either he or his mom would travel home for New Year’s Eve. Since Matt’s dad had died when Matt was just a baby, he and his mom were especially close. The rare Christmases he didn’t fly home he spent with the Baldwins after he swung by Cait’s house to open presents. She’d spent plenty of her own Christmases with Tristan’s family as well, but usually not until Christmas Day evening when she couldn’t take any more of her mother, sisters, and assorted nieces and nephews.
Their lives were fully enmeshed and had been for so long. She was terrified what they’d done would change that, but the alternative was pretending she could handle seeing where things went between the three of them. And that was just not…feasible. She wasn’t that sort of woman. If she was, why had she waited so long to have sex in the first place?
Maybe because you knew once you started, you’d be a raging maniac. Genes will tell. Look what’s happened so far.
“Sure you can,” Tristan said, his voice free of rancor. “To prove it to you, we’ll go out to eat for your birthday.”
“We always go out together for my birthday. What’s new about that?”
“This will be a real date, with both of us. We’ll take you someplace romantic and spoil you rotten.”
She snorted at Matt, shaking her head. “You never spoil me. You're too cheap. Tristan's the spoiler.”
“He only has the money to spoil you because I rein in his damn spending.”
“No, he only has the money to spoil me because I’m such an awesome designer and make you both so much money,” she teased, patting his chest.
“Yeah, well, I design too,” Tristan interjected. “I also go out and get most of our clients, so I think I’ve earned the right to spend the money I make from the business with my name on it.”
“You may be awesome, but he spends it almost as fast as you make it, kid.”
“Love when you guys talk about me like I’m not even here,” Tristan said, turning his face into Cait’s neck. “Makes me wonder what it is I see in you.”
“Me, it’s my big breasts.” Cait grinned at her less than noteworthy chest.
“And me, it’s my big…well, I won’t brag in front of the lady.”
She rolled her eyes. “More like won’t tell lies in front of the lady.”
“Didn’t hear you complaining earlier,” Matt said, pulling her mouth to his for a slow, simmering kiss. “Either of you, for that matter,” he added against her lips.
“Tristan’s is bigger.” She laughed when Matt yanked on her hair. “You’re just an overachiever.”
“See why I love her?” Tristan grinned and cuddled her closer, though Matt immediately wrapped an arm around her waist and snuggled in as well. “She has exquisite powers of perception.”
“Remind me he gets your ass, then.”
She stiffened before she could stop herself. Tristan’s head came up, and she knew he was giving Matt the evil eye. “We won’t do anything you don’t want,” he said in the same voice he'd used to soothe her forever. “If you’d rather we not do that, we won’t. Plenty of other things we can occupy ourselves with.”
“I’m not sure about a date,” she said instead of replying to his comment. “Dates imply kissing and holding hands and—”
“And you giving us a chance to be with you before you slam the door on us,” Matt said, surprising her by jumping in before Tristan could. “One date. What’s the big deal?”
He had a point. It was only one night. “Where?”
“That's a surprise.”
“Someplace up here. Not back home. I don't want to chance running into anyone.”