“I think you know that I am,” she answered. “I think you have always known.”
He blinked, slowly, but did not immediately reply, gripping the pillow in his lap a little tighter.
“Does it surprise you?” she asked, glancing down at the drip of wax near her skirt and then back at him, “that I played in dares as a child? You have not said so, but I suspect your perception of me does not lend itself to such mischief.”
He inhaled very slowly. “I suppose it didn’t,” he admitted, “until just now.”
She nodded, staring down at the flames. “People always think because I am kind, I am weak. That because I am gentle, I am afraid. And that because I am shy, I am innocent. I am not.”
“Not … afraid?” he managed to ask, his throat going dry.
She raised her eyes to meet his. “Not innocent,” she clarified, her voice clear and even. “And no, not afraid, either.”
They stared at one another for a moment, suspended in light and clatter. Julian thought that if he could breathe, he would hear the very air entering and exiting his body. That if his heartbeat were audible, it would be just as fast as the collision of hailstones above.
“Innocence is not black and white,” he finally managed to say, a bit harsher than he’d intended, but true all the same. “Naivety, by necessity, requires a lack of context.”
“Perhaps it does,” she said. “Julian, I have lived in the capitals of the known world, as a working woman, alone and in the company of libertines and maestros and all that is fashionable. Do you really think naivety can survive all that?”
He paused, frowning. She made a decent point. He considered the argument, and considered her, sitting on that sideboard like it were a particularly perverse witness stand.
“All right,” he said, “I’ll allow naivety is unlikely to survive such environs. But knowledge and connotation do not, by necessity, meet the same thresholds as experience.”
She bit her lip, a little titter bubbling up in her. “You think that I have heard salacious gossip but remained chaste in my company of dress forms, sequestered from vice? That is your assumption? And it is based on nothing but my comport, I would wager? Who is bearding the lion now?”
His mouth dropped open, his jaw aching at the shock of it. “Miss Thresher!”
“‘Monica,’” she corrected. “Weren’t you just telling me I shouldn’t build assumptions on the pretense of presentation? Or implying that I oughtn’t have, where you are concerned?”
“I said no such thing,” he protested, blood rushing in his ears.
“No, I suppose you didn’t,” she said with a shrug. “But you implied it.”
He scoffed, stammering a syllable and then another and then clamping his mouth shut and glaring at the woman across from him. “That isn’t what ‘bearding the lion’ means.”
She pressed her lips inward on each other, like she was holding in a laugh. “Oh?” she said. “Is it not?”
“I am your barrister,” he reminded her, jaw still aching as he clamped his molars together. “There is a … an ethical … There is a line, Monica …”
“And I oughtn’t cross it to tug at your mane?” she asked, blinking at him innocently.
“You oughtn’t ever tug on a lion’s mane,” he answered, this time unconcerned with the harshness in his tone, “unless you are willing to contend with not outrunning him afterward.”
“Ah, I see, I see,” she said, nodding. “I have not made it clear enough, then? That I do not mind being caught in the lion’s maw?”
Again, there was a beat of silence. A rumble of thunder as they stared at one another.
But this time, the clicking of hailstones seemed to have ceased. And the candlelight was stymied by the rays of sunlight piercing through the storm clouds as they began to shudder and disperse in the sky beyond the window.
His shoulders sagged, and he was not certain whether the feeling in them, that release of tension, was relief or disappointment.
Monica sighed and tore her eyes from his, glancing out the window.
And then she leaned over, and without any preamble or performance, extinguished all three flames with the pinch of her bare fingers.
Chapter Thirteen
Monica busied herself with the necessary tasks at the breaking of the storm. Her hands could not shake if they were in the service of a task, after all, and in a half-built shop interior, there were many tasks.