“So you decided you’d rather decorate houses?” I put my drink down and glanced between the men. “Was there an application process?”
Cooper reached for his beer, his shoulder brushing mine. “He hired himself halfway through the job.”
“I identified an opportunity and had the connections and resources to get the ball really rolling.” Jensen shifted his attention back to me. “You grew up on the East Coast, right?”
“We moved around a lot.” I peeled a damp corner of my coaster. “Eventually we landed in a suburb of Boston.”
Luke angled toward me, his knee still warm against mine. “What brought you to California?”
Fair question for a date, but the answer made me want to crawl under the table and inspect the gum collection. I could give them the fresh-start version. Technically accurate, if I left out whose idea it had been.
“I moved here from New York with my boyfriend.” I rolled the wet piece of cardboard I’d peeled between my fingers. “He dumped me a few weeks later.”
Jensen’s grin disappeared. Beside me, Cooper went still, and Luke’s hand returned to my thigh and squeezed.
Then our server appeared with our food. I moved the glasses out of the way with perhaps too much enthusiasm.
By the time we’d finished eating, the conversation about the reasons for my cross-country move had been forgotten, or at least pushed to the back burner. The focus was solely on the available air hockey table Cooper had been eyeing since we’d gotten the check.
I stood on one side of the table while Cooper rolled his sleeves to his elbows and cracked his neck like a prizefighter. He thought he was being fair by playing with his left hand instead of his right, but quickly learned that hockey did, in fact, run in my blood.
I scored first, a lucky bank shot, and he stared at the goal for a full second before looking at me with narrowed eyes. After that, he came alive. He crouched and smacked the puck so hard it ricocheted off the rail and nearly took out Jensen’s beer sitting on the side.
He was a tough competitor, but I was also distracted by Luke and Jensen watching. When Cooper won, he did a small, restrained shimmy with his shoulders.
I stared. There was no way he just shimmied. “Was that a special little dance?”
“No.” He straightened and unrolled his sweater sleeves, absolutely smug.
“I’m going to think about that shimmy for the rest of my life.”
He walked to my side of the table to collect my mallet. His hand wrapped over mine, and his gaze dropped to my mouth, the teasing smile fading. Luke and Jensen had drifted into the noise somewhere behind us.
Cooper leaned in slowly and his lips barely brushed mine. “Good, because I’d hate to be forgettable.”
He took the mallet and stepped back, leaving me wanting more but also very aware we were in public.
A pinball machine started shrieking and I did a quick pivot, remembering there were two other men on this date. Jensen stood in front of a pinball machine with his jaw set and his shoulders square, working the flippers like the fate of the world rested on a steel ball.
Luke leaned against the machine beside him with his arms folded and delivered commentary in a hushed golf-announcer voice. “Quinn is under tremendous pressure now. The crowd has gone silent. He’s thinking about his family. He’s thinking about his tax returns. He’s wondering if he’s made the right choices in life.”
As I came to stand beside Luke, two balls disappeared down the drain in quick succession, leaving Jensen with one.
“The pressure mounts,” Luke whispered. “All eyes are on Jensen Quinn as he makes the final run to impress the lady.”
Jensen failed to hit the last ball and he slapped the side of the machine. “Damn it, Luke!”
“Rest in peace, high score.” Luke patted Jensen’s shoulder.
I was laughing so hard I had to grip Luke’s arm.
Jensen glared at both of us. “I take this very seriously.”
“I can tell. You get a little line right here.” I stepped closer and pressed my finger between his brows. “It’s kind of cute.”
He gently caught my wrist. “Cute?” The arcade lights flashed over his face. “I’ll show you cute.”
He led me to the claw machine in the back, tucked beside a few Skee-Ball lanes.