“What would you propose instead?”
“Stewardship. Not consultation.” I push the second document across. “A joint body. Co-equal directorship — one Alliance, one Kaleidian, appointed by the tribal council and removable only by it. Every research program requires both signatures. Every publication requires both. Every physical entry into the basin requires a tribal escort who has the authority to end the visit on the spot, without appeal, without giving a reason.”
“That’s a veto.”
“It’s a veto.”
“You understand what you’re asking. You’re asking my directorate to fund four hundred personnel and hand a stop switch to a council that has existed for nine weeks.”
“Yes.”
“Why would I accept that?”
“Because the alternative is worse for you specifically,” I say, “and I’d rather make that argument than a moral one, because moral arguments don’t survive a change of administrator.”
She sits back.
“Go on.”
“You want the archive. Not the ruins — the archive, the nine worlds, the deployment order, the fourth-revision design. That’s the prize, as we both know, and it isn’t buried. It sits in a language nobody in your directorate reads, in a room that wakes only when a Kaleidian stands on the floor plate barefoot.” I hold her eyes. “You cannot take that. You can’t excavate it, you can’t ship it, and if you force the issue you’ll get four hundred meters of very interesting stone and a species that stops standing on it. The one version where you learn anything is the one where they still want you here in twenty years.”
The room is extremely quiet.
“You’re telling me my leverage is worthless,” Vantrell says.
“I’m telling you your leverage is time-limited and theirs isn’t. That’s an unusual position for your directorate, and a week to sit with it has not yet been available.”
She says nothing for a while. Then she does something I didn’t expect: she turns to Varesh.
“Elder. Is she right?”
Varesh, four days into this with his ribs strapped and his eyes half shut, does not open them.
“The room lit for Sethiel,” he says. “It woke for Ryska, and for a hill-clan midwife who had never seen a machine. It has not lit once for a human, and your Doctor Solis has now tried it eleven times with instruments I do not understand and she will tell you the same.” He does open his eyes then. “We are not being clever, Administrator. We simply cannot give you the thing you want. We can only stand inside and report what it says.”
Vantrell looks at that old man for a while.
“That’s the strongest negotiating position I’ve encountered in nineteen years,” she says, “and the irritating part is that you aren’t negotiating.”
It takes another six days.
She fights me hard on the removal clause and I give ground on the appointment process instead. She wants publication rights on anything with medical application and I trade her a fast-track annex for a hard cap on personnel. Torvak nearly walks out twice. Ynara saves it both times with a procedural point that I am certain she invents on the spot.
On the eleventh day we have a draft.
Joint Stewardship of the Kalei Interior — co-equal directorship, tribal veto on entry, no extraction in perpetuity, personnel capped at one hundred and forty, review every four years by both parties, and a clause I fought for over three separate sessions: the Kaleidian directorship is not advisory, is not honorary, and cannot be filled by Alliance appointment even temporarily.
It is not what I would design with a free hand. It has three compromises in it that will cause somebody grief in a decade.
It is, by an enormous margin, the best framework any pre-contact world has ever signed.
The chiefs carry it off to argue over, which is correct, and Torvak sends word the second night that Stonefang will consider it, which from him is practically enthusiasm, and Ynara says only that she wants the review interval shortened to three years and that she will say so herself.
That evening Vantrell joins me outside with a cup of something Riverwind brews that I have not asked about.
“You could have had my job,” she says. “Ten years ago, easily. Why didn’t you?”
“I like being outside.”