“That’s the part the record doesn’t answer.” Camille turns the slate around regardless, being constitutionally incapable of withholding data. “But it does answer something else. Look at the deployment order. Kalei is the seventh. And the ring here isn’t the first design — it’s the fourth revision. They got better at this nine times.”
Natalie has gone motionless beside me, the way she does.
“Say it,” I tell her.
“Nine rings, nine keeper peoples, and one was still walking about four hundred thousand years later carrying the last component to funerals.” She looks up. “Kheron, we’re not the interesting part of this room. The interesting part is the other eight.”
Nobody sleeps much after that.
I call the war council out of habit and then, halfway through convening it, I stop myself and call something else instead — every chief who can travel, plus Varesh, plus the humans, plus, at Ynara’s suggestion, four people who are not chiefs at all: a Riverwind fisher, a Stonefang stonecutter, a hill-clan midwife, and Kavik, who tries three times to refuse and is refused his refusal.
We meet in the painted cave. It seemed correct.
“Here is the decision,” I tell them, “and understand that the answer escapes me and I refuse to pretend otherwise. There are nine rooms under the interior basin. Their contents are worth more than every mine and timber stand on this world combined, and the galaxy does not know it exists.”
Torvak, whose arm has healed badly and who has stopped complaining about it: “Then it stays not knowing.”
“That was my first thought as well.”
“It is the correct thought. Four centuries of shut gates kept this world whole. The first season we open them, a syndicate cuts a trench in the Sunfall Basin and my galleries fall down.”
“Halloran did not come through an open gate,” Ynara says. “He came through a closed one, quietly, with a chief’s help, and it took us eleven weeks to notice. That is what closed gates buy. Not safety — delay, and the delay is spent by whoever is already inside.”
That lands hard. Torvak lets that stand.
Natalie speaks last, at my request, having spent three days trying to talk me out of the request.
“Let me be careful here,” she says, “since I’m the only person in this cave who isn’t from this planet, and I’ve watched what happens when someone like me starts telling a people what’s good for them.” Her hands rest flat on her knees. “So I’ll only give you the part I actually know, which is the arithmetic.
“There are two ways this gets out. You tell it, or somebody finds it. If you tell it, you set the terms — who comes, how many, what they may touch, what it costs them. If somebody finds it, they set the terms, and by the time you’re in the room the terms are four years old and written somewhere you’ve never been.
“And somebody will find it. Not because your security is bad. Because a planet stopped a solar catastrophe eleven weeks ago and forty Alliance instruments recorded it from orbit, and Halloran is standing trial in a courtroom where every word is transcribed, and Rhakor sold packets to people who resold them.” She lets that sit. “The secret is already leaking. What you still own is the first sentence. That’s worth more than you’d think, and it has a very short life.”
The cave is peaceful for a while.
“You would have us open the gate,” Sethiel says.
“I’m telling you the gate is coming off its hinges and you can either take it down yourselves or have it taken down. That’s not advice, Elder. It’s a weather report.”
Later, once the chiefs have gone off to argue in smaller rooms as chiefs do, I find her at the eleventh panel with a hand lamp, looking at the kneeling figure.
“You were right to make me ask you,” she says.
“I nearly did not.”
“I know. I could see you deciding.” She turns the lamp so the gold band shows. “Kheron, whatever your council lands on, hear something, and hear it from me before anybody else says it in a worse way. If you open this world, some of what comes through will be good — medicine, water systems, the survey work I could never fund. And some will be people of the kind I spend my career fighting, and they will be polite, and they will have permits.”
“I know.”
“You don’t yet, but you will.” She lifts her chin. “The other thing is that once this is public, I stop being the strange offworlder your elder tolerates. I become the human who was standing next to the war leader when a Precursor archive opened. There will be noise, and much of it will be about me, and some of it will be about us.”
“Let it be.”
“That’s easy to say in a cave.”
“Then I will say it in a council, and before a delegation, and to whoever else requires it.” I lift the lamp from her hand and set it down so her face is visible. “Natalie. Three months ago I refused to tell you what you were to me because I was afraid you would hear a cage. I have been paying for that caution ever since, in small ways, and I am finished with it. Whatever comes through that gate can find us standing together where the light is good.”
She is silent.