“Whose order?”
“Nobody’s. Theirs.” He winces as I work. “That’s what I mean. They had us. Doctor, at eleven thousand a cruiser does not sit broadside unless it wants you to see how big it is.”
Before the day is out I have four more of the same. A pilot who flew an escort through a gap that stayed open for six minutes. A boarding crew that was shot at with what he describes, professionally, as bad marksmanship. Vorn, who says only that in two hundred years he has never been permitted to withdraw in good order and does not like how it felt.
I take it to Soryn, who has been reading the shape of such things since long before my grandmother.
He hears the whole account without interrupting, and at the end he closes his eyes briefly.
“They opened a door for you,” he says.
“Varek said the same. He put it as a door they left open.”
“It is older than that, Doctor.” He folds his hands. “There is a passage in the war chronicles that I have never included in the archive, having no way to corroborate it and had no wish to be accused of decorating. It describes the third year. It says the Coalition stopped destroying Ishani refugee convoys and began letting one ship in every four escape.”
I sink onto the bench.
“Escape where?”
“Home,” Soryn says. “To wherever the ship believed home was. Each was followed. That is how they found the second colony, and the third, and the harbor at Vessik where forty thousand people were sheltering.” He opens his eyes. “It is not a new tactic. It is their oldest one, it has never failed them, and we have just performed it exactly as written.”
I find Varek down among the seed trays well past midnight, because of course that is where he is.
The shoots have come on. Somebody kept them watered right through, and I badly want to know who.
He is on the crate with his hands hanging loose, and he never lifts his head when I come in.
“Nineteen,” he says. “And Dessa. And the transport.”
“I know.”
“I have written the letter to her mother four times.”
I sit down next to him.
“Say the remainder,” I prompt. “You’ve been building it since the command deck.”
“I knew,” he says. “There it is entire. I stood at that chart and told you I could not separate the evidence from what I wanted, and I went anyway, and now there are nineteen graves and a scout who cannot sleep and a girl of ninety-one who will not get older, and I knew.”
“You did know.”
“Then say the thing you came to say.”
“That is not why I came.” I take one of his hands, which requires both of mine. “You knew it might be a trap. You had no way of knowing that it was, and that distinction is not semantic, because Sebrine Arno is asleep in my third ward right now and there are six hundred people asleep in the schools who would be dead in the dark if you had been right about yourself.”
“Eleven of them died in our hangar.”
“Eleven died. The rest of them did not.” I make him look at me. “Varek. He did not trick you into a mistake. He built a situation in which the correct action and the ruinous action were the same action, and then he waited. That is not a failure of your judgment. That is a man who understood your judgment perfectly and used it as a component.”
He is a long time answering.
“If I had refused it,” he says, “they would have died, and this rock would still be hidden, and I would stand in this shed telling myself I had done the responsible thing.”
“Yes.”
“I would have preferred that,” he says. “There lies the thing I cannot pardon. Some part of me would have preferred it.”
“That part of you is sixty years old and kept your people alive,” I say. “It’s allowed to speak. It just doesn’t get to vote anymore.”