Page 88 of Final Cut

Page List

Font Size:

“I would be bad for you. I know my own track record.”

“Cole.” He hooks his fingers under my chin, forcing me to look at him. “Do you really believe that? Do you really think it’s your fault that Clara took her own life?”

I open my mouth on an automatic “yes”, but Quin narrows his eyes and the word dies on my tongue.

“You said you looked through seven years of text messages,” he says. “And I’m assuming you’ve spent the last three years reliving seven years’ worth of memories. So, tell me honestly—do you really think it was your fault?”

My temper surges up like a fountain.

“It wasn’t her fault,” I snap, knocking his hand away from my face. “Don’t you fucking dare say that.”

“I wasn’t going to.”

“You were thinking it.”

“No,” he says. “I wasn’t. It wasn’t her fault, and it wasn’t yours.”

“It was my fault. I was supposed to make her happy.”

He lets out a heavy breath. “Would you be blaming yourself like this if Clara had died of cancer?”

“Yes,” I say.

His mouth curves humorlessly. “I believe that. But you’d probably know, intellectually, that you shouldn’t.”

“It’s not the same thing.”

He raises an eyebrow. “Is that really the hill you want to let yourself die on? That mental illnesses aren’t as real as physical ones?”

“I didn’t say that,” I snap. “I know that they are. You have no idea—you don’t know how many fucking psychiatrists I’ve talked to. I’m practically single-handedly funding the Canadian suicide hotline⁠—”

“You are?”

“—I’ve talked to people who’ve tried to kill themselves, and people who want to kill themselves, and families who’ve lost people to suicide, and it’s not—it isn’t—it doesn’t fit,” I burst out. “Nothing they say makes it make sense. And don’t tell me mental illness doesn’t have to make sense, I’ve heard that bullshit before.”

“It’s not bullshit.”

“It is! It is. You can’t—you don’t understand. She wouldn’t have done that to me.”

I don’t mean to say the last part out loud. It sounds so pathetic, so selfish, like I’m only sad for myself instead of her. But it’s not a lie. After all these years, I still don’t believe she would do that to me. Clara and I, we looked after each other. That was our whole fucking thing. She was an introvert, and most people annoyed me, but it didn’t matter. I was her person, and she was mine. Our whole life was the two of us.

Quin drags his lower lip through his teeth. “Then maybe it wasn’t what it looked like.”

Hearing him say it actually hurts, like he’s punched me in the sternum. “You don’t think I’ve thought of that? I spent months, years, trying to prove that someone killed her.”

Every dollar I ever earned in my life, I spent on private investigators. Then, when all of that was gone, I spent hundreds of thousands of my father’s money on more. It didn’t matter. They all came to the same awful conclusion.

“Maybe they didn’t have all the evidence,” Quin says tentatively.

I shake my head jerkily. “They did.”

As loathe as I am to give Nathan Hart any kind of credit, he did cooperate with the people I hired—the first four or five of them, anyway. He gave them the police reports, the crime scene photos, the witness statements. When he got fed up of dealing with them, he gave it all to me. And as much as I’d like to believe he did it to hurt me, I think the truth is even worse. He was the first one on scene at Clara’s death, the one who found her, and I think he was tired of reliving it. I think, in his own stupid little mind, he thought Clara would go back to him someday. I don’t think he’s ever forgiven me for taking that chance away.

“Maybe they missed something,” Quin says.

“One set of footprints,” I say, with a weariness that threatens to suffocate me. “I saw the photos myself. Clara drove herself to Lake Packett—an old lady saw her car go by—and she walked out onto the lake by herself, and she died by herself. That’s what happened. I can’t change it.”

Quin watches me for a long, exquisitely painful moment, then he steps close and puts his palms onto my chest. “Then you have to let it go.”


Novels you may like ...