It feels like another turning point, an opportunity to dig my heels in or flee. I climb into the car and squeeze the steering wheel, trying to think rationally and look past my fears. Ava’s death was a drug deal gone wrong, that’s what Officer Hart said. It doesn’t make it okay, it doesn’t mean she deserved it, but it’s not the same as a random serial killer strangling women for sport.
It was a drug deal gone wrong, and the guy who killed her was trying to hide her body in the woods to avoid getting caught. He’ll be laying low now, hiding out from the cops. He’s not going to be worrying about some random actor who saw him, one who already told the police everything he knows. And he’s not going to do anything that would draw more attention to himself, like coming after me. If he has any sense at all, he’ll have already left town, or maybe even fled the province.
I let out a slow breath, my fingers loosening on the wheel. When I think about it like that, it seems a lot simpler. All of the tall men out on the street start looking like normal, pleasant strangers again.
“No, thanks,” I tell Kel firmly. “I’ll be fine.”
19
Quin
I’ve never watched a rom-com defiantly before, but tonight, that’s exactly what I’m doing. I’ve got a homemade pizza in the oven and a glass of red wine in my hand, and I’m halfway through Runaway Bride. When it’s over, I’m going to watch My Best Friend’s Wedding, and if I’m still not tired after that, I’ll tack on Pretty Woman and make it a Julia Roberts trifecta. I’ve got a fire going in the fireplace and the front door is locked, and I’m not thinking about the guy in the woods or letting my irrational fears get the best of me.
I miss a Facetime call from Trevor and Jonathan while I’m taking the pizza out of the oven, but I text them back that I’ll call them tomorrow. If I talk to them now, I know I’ll end up spilling out all my worries, and saying them out loud might make them feel more real. Jonathan’s imagination will jump to the same scary conclusions that mine did, and then Trevor will have to talk both of us down. Or, worse, they’ll spend a bunch of money to fly out here and be with me, like Trevor offered to do when I told them about finding the body. They’ve got two games left in their volleyball season before the holiday break, and I don’t want them to skip out on them because of me. Better to wait and talk to them tomorrow, when my nerves have settled down a bit.
That would happen a lot faster if this damn cabin would stop making so many noises. It’s windy again tonight, and every few minutes, something creaks or groans. I know that it’s nothing, I know that I heard all the same sounds last night, but I can’t stop myself from noticing them. I keep pausing the movie to listen, then calling myself an idiot and restarting it again.
Cameron Diaz and Julia Roberts are having their face-off in the women’s restroom when there’s a particularly loud thump from outside. I sit bolt upright and pause the movie again. I don’t think I’ve heard that sound before.
I look to the window, but all I can see is my own frightened reflection. The firelight creates strange, flickering shadows behind me, and for a moment I swear I see something move in the kitchen.
I whip around, but there’s nothing there. Of course there isn’t. How many people have heard strange thumps in their houses, or seen weird shadows, and how many of them have actually been murdered? I don’t know the answer, but it must be a fraction of a fraction of a percent. We all just think it’ll happen to us because we grew up watching too many scary movies.
If this were a movie, the shadow in the kitchen would be a red herring. I’d turn back to the window and the killer would be there, instead, standing with his face pressed against the glass.
A chill creeps up my neck.
This is stupid. I’m being stupid.
I turn back to the window slowly, with my heart somewhere up in my throat.
There isn’t anyone there, obviously. But now I can’t get that image out of my head.
I know what I have to do. I have to get up, and go outside, and prove to myself that there’s nothing out there. If I don’t, I’m never going to be able to go to sleep tonight.
I know I have to do it, but it takes several minutes to work up the nerve to move.
I turn the movie back on—if I’m about to be murdered, at least I’ll have Julia and Cameron to witness the crime—and walk to the door, wincing every time the floor creaks. As I hover for a moment with my hand on the doorknob, there’s another loud thump from outside. My breath catches from fear. My heart starts pounding rabbit-fast.
In one quick motion, I yank open the door.
The porch is empty, just like I knew, deep down, it would be. I let out a breath and take a cautious step outside. It’s freezing out, even colder than last night, but I pad out to the top of the steps in my socked feet and peer out at the driveway. There’s nothing out of the ordinary there, and the forest is dark and quiet and still.
Thump.
Something white flashes in the trees. For a split second, I’m scared again, then there’s another flash of white, and another soft, deep thump.
My legs go weak with relief. There’s a stumpy pine tree near the house that’s been bent sideways ever since the first snowstorm. The weight of the snow on its branches must’ve finally reached a tipping point, and the thumps I heard were clumps of snow falling to the ground. As I stand there watching, another huge chunk slides off, and the tree springs up a little bit straighter, happy to be free of the weight.
“You scared the shit out of me,” I tell it sternly, then I laugh a little, slightly shaky with leftover fear.
I’m about to go back inside when my gaze catches on the tree line. The sky is overcast tonight, but in the space between the clouds and the trees, there’s a faint tinge of green.
My heart leaps. It’s the Northern Lights again. Someone at work said they might be back tonight, but I forgot all about it until now. If I hadn’t come outside, I would’ve missed it, and if that’s not a sign from the universe, I don’t know what is.
With a surge of sudden energy, I go back inside and start pulling on my winter things. I’m going to walk to the lake again, and I’ll stop at Cole’s place and ask him if I can take Bandit with me. He’ll probably insist on coming with us, and maybe that’s what the universe is pointing me toward. Another chance to spend time with Cole.
He’s been at the back of my mind all day, a constant, nagging presence I can’t shake. He was right last night, when he said that I don’t know him at all. But I want to. For better or worse, I want to know him more.