Page 91 of Unlikely Pair

Page List

Font Size:

I trail off, realizing that I brought up Hailey.

“I’m sorry, Sutton.”

“For what?”

“I…I shouldn’t talk about Hailey.”

“Why not?” she says, and though I can’t see her face to confirm it, she sounds genuine. “She was your wife. She’s Adalyn’s mother. She was a part of your life for a very long time. There’s never a reason to apologize for talking about her.”

“I know…it’s just…” I don’t know what I’m trying to say. And somehow, yet again, Sutton does it for me.

“Even though I’m your fake girlfriend, you feel bad about talking about your wife?”

I let out a relieved breath. “Something like that.”

“Well don’t feel bad. Ever. Honestly? I’d love to know more about her. From what I read when it happened, and how you talk about her, she really seems like someone I could’ve been friends with.”

You could have. You really could have.

“I think she would’ve liked you.”

“It’s because of the bedazzles, right? That usually wins people over.”

I laugh and tell her the story about how Hailey tried to make her own sign with glitter and gems once, but she didn’t let it dry before holding it up so it looked like Adalyn made it in preschool.

“That’s amazing,” she says, laughing at the anecdote. “I’m now picturing an alternate reality where life didn’t hand you the biggest fuck you of all time, and I made Hailey a bedazzled denim jacket and she wore it to tell my ex off when she saw him with another woman.”

I laugh at that thought. “Even in your alternate universe Rob is still a cheating asshole?”

“I’m shifting paradigms, not completely alternating universes.”

Thinking about a life where Hailey and Sutton would’ve been friends shouldn’t make me smile, but somehow it does.

And I have a feeling it’s because of Sutton.

“Can I ask you something?” I say, breaking the silence.

“Of course.”

“When I called earlier. You seemed surprised.”

Sutton doesn’t say anything for a second, and I don’t push her. I know better than anyone that sometimes you don’t want to say things out loud, or if you do, you don’t know how. I have a feeling she’s wrestling between those decisions now.

“I was.”

“Can I ask why?”

“Because,” she says, and I hear her suck in a breath before continuing. “You actually called.”

I feel like I’m missing something. “But I told you I would.”

“I know,” she says. “I’m just not used to that.”

The gravity of those words hits me square in the chest.

“Well, get used to it,” I say. “Because I’m a man of my word. And when I say I’m going to do something, I do it.”

“That’s sweet, Asher. And I didn’t mean to put you on some sort of spot, or make it some pity party for me, because obviously not everyone always comes through⁠—”


Novels you may like ...