“I’ve been telling you to lighten up for years. I thought maybe the middle of the night was the time you did it.”
We share a soft smile as she takes my hands in hers again. “All I’m trying to say is that I know it’s hard. And no one—not you, not Adalyn, not me—will ever think that you seeing someone new means you don’t love Hailey.”
And there it is. The true reason why dating scares the hell out of me. The one I’ve been too scared to admit to myself. That I’d never say out loud. Leave it to Mom to just cut to the chase with it.
“I’ll always love her.”
“Of course you will. And you’ll never forget her. That little girl upstairs is proof of that.”
A tear falls down my cheek, and I can’t hold them back. “I will, Mom. One day, I’ll get out there again. I promise. Just…not yet. There are some things in my head I need to work out before I’m ready.”
“I can live with that,” she says, patting my leg. “But can I say one thing?”
“If I say no will that stop you?”
“Not even a little bit,” she says with a smile. “I know you’re feeling pressured right now to date, and that’s not helping you come to terms with it. You’re stubborn. Always have been. And you’re not going to do anything if it’s not your idea. And, because you like to double down on those kinds of things, if people want you to do it, you’re going to not do it even more.”
I can’t even defend myself. She’s right. My dad wanted me to be a goalie when I was younger. I went on a hockey strike for a month.
“I just wish they’d listen to me when I say I’m not ready. How hard is that?”
“It’s not, but they’re doing it out of a place of love. Just know though, the longer you stay single…the longer you don’t even try…the hassling isn’t going to stop. And neither are advances like one from the Erikas in your life.”
“I know,” I say with a groan. “But how do I get them off my back? I don’t know how to say no any other way besides taking up a foreign language.”
“That I don’t know. All I’m saying is, if you had a girlfriend, or someone you were regularly seeing, it would keep the Erikas of the world away. And maybe cool down the talk that you don’t want to be getting from your friends. And then you can eventually date on your timeline.”
Mom has a point. The second Sutton stepped between me and Erika tonight—heck, even just sitting near me—it seemed to push her back a little. And I know that if I told the Poker Club, and Liam and Finn, that I was seeing someone, they’d ease off and just ask me annoying questions about the relationship. That seems like a better option than them meddling in my life.
I’m still not ready to date date, but the idea of a girlfriend of some sort does seem a little more attractive now.
Just not an actual one. But a fake one…
“Asher? What’s going through that brain of yours?”
I’ve never been a talkative guy, and everyone always just assumes it’s because I have nothing to say. But not my mom. She always knows when I have something to say, but I’m just not ready, or willing, to say it.
“Just…something.”
My idea isn’t even fully cooked yet, so I dare not say any of it out loud.
“Well whatever it is, sleep on it,” she says, standing up and kissing my forehead. “No one makes good decisions at two in the morning.”
She’s right about that. So I think about it at three a.m. And at four. It’s the last thought I have when I finally doze off somewhere around five. And when Adalyn comes bounding down the stairs at eight, waking me from my uncomfortable slumber on the couch, it’s my first thought.
I’m going to ask Sutton to be my fake girlfriend.
CHAPTER 14
SUTTON
“Alright, sweetie, I’m going to have you sit back and relax. You have about thirty minutes to process. Can I get you anything?”
“I’m good,” my client says as she grabs her phone. “Now go in the back and eat lunch.”
I laugh as I check her foils one more time. “How did you know it’s my lunch break?”
“Girl, I heard your stomach growling twenty minutes ago. Go. I’m fine here. I have my phone and an eight-part ‘Am I The Asshole’ story to catch up on.”