Page 40 of Unlikely Pair

Page List

Font Size:

“You’re both idiots,” I say, turning away from them to grab my shower caddy so I can get the hell back to the hotel where I’m going to take an amazing pre-game nap. “But since you two won’t drop it, we’d met before. Maverick takes dance class with Adalyn, and, coincidentally enough, she’s the one who fixed Adalyn’s haircut that she gave herself last week.”

I expect the two of them to say something smart, or stupid, however you look at it. But neither of them do. They just stare at me with this…look…in their eyes. It’s…alarming.

“Whatever it is, just come out and say it,” I plead. “The quicker we get this conversation over with, the quicker I’m out of here.”

The two look at each other, having a weird silent conversation, before Liam speaks up. “We were just thinking…you two seemed to get along well. And have some things in common.”

“And, I don’t know,” Finn interrupts. “Maybe Sutton would be a good person to maybe go on a date with?”

“Absolutely not,” I say, grabbing my towel.

“Why not?” Liam asks. “She’s pretty.”

“Very pretty,” Finn adds.

“Also has a kid,” Liam continues, “so I’m sure she has the same kinds of rules and guidelines and must haves that you do. And you just said you two already know each other. It’s perfect.”

“Have you forgotten that I’m not interested in dating?” I defend. “That seems to be the detail you two always pass over.”

“But if you were,” Liam presses, “wouldn’t it be someone like Sutton?”

God forbid I say this out loud, but he’s right, it would be. In the few times we’ve interacted, she seems like a really good person. Perky. A smile on her face even when she’s in a situation where she shouldn’t have to smile at all. The kind of woman who works on her day off to help a kid who gave herself a shitty haircut.

A beautiful woman who can wear the hell out of a dress.

My mind rewinds back to the party. It was just the two of us at the table, and for a while, I lost track of time. We were talking about everything and nothing. Mostly about our kids and things they’re either into or fads we’ve been desperate to keep away from them, but it was nice. Nothing awkward. Just a nice conversation with a nice woman.

“In theory, yes,” I agree, needing to push those thoughts aside. “But, are you both forgetting that the father of her child is our teammate? Locker room 101: Don’t date a teammate’s ex.”

“But…and hear me out…” Finn says. “What if we like the ex better than the teammate?”

Well, that’s true. “Still. It’s messy. I don’t do drama, you know this.”

“Yes, we know,” the two say with simultaneous whines.

“Thank you. Now can I go shower? Or do we need to keep talking about hypothetical situations with Sutton?”

“Sutton? As in my Sutton?”

I look to my right to see Rob standing with his arms crossed, staring at me, the two rookies who follow him around like puppy dogs standing on either side.

“Is she yours?” I challenge. “Because from what I gathered at your party, when you speak about Sutton, it should be in past tense.”

“You don’t know shit,” Rob says, his face turning red. “Plus, whatever she told you about me is a fucking lie.”

More than ninety percent of the time, when it comes to drama or squabbles between teammates, I stay out of it. I’ll make sure it doesn’t escalate into a fight, but I’m not a captain, so I maintain a safe distance from the dustups whenever possible.

But when it comes to Mercer? I’ll get in on that. Because the guy A) doesn’t know when to shut the fuck up; and B) has it coming for being a huge fucking prick.

“She didn’t tell me much,” I say, which seems to calm him down for a second. “But she did confirm for me that she’s your ex, you have a child with her, and you left her for her sister, who you’re now marrying. I know guys who have types, but I haven’t met many where the type was one family.”

I don’t say much in the locker room, so my monologue is starting to gain an audience, especially with the ones who hadn’t heard of the family connections Rob has tangled himself into.

“Did you really leave her for her sister?” Liam asks, even though I know he already knows the answer to that. “That’s fucked up.”

“And how is that going to work?” Finn asks. “Are you his dad? His uncle? Oh! You can be his duncle!”

Our teammates snicker at Finn’s comment—that is, everyone except Rob.


Novels you may like ...