And by sometimes, I mean all the time. Because what the four of us do here is a secret. No one knows. Not even Gabi, who, along with her ties to Beau and Maddox, is the manager of Sugar and Sweets, the bakery we use for our clandestine meetings. Because sometimes four professional athletes need a place to go to get away from the game. To separate ourselves from the pressures of our jobs. Where no media is going to run into us or fans are going to stop us and ask for an autograph.
Someplace we can go just to bake.
Our secret started just over two years ago, but it wasn’t just Theo, Beau, and I getting together and saying “you know what would be fun? Baking together.” I’m pretty sure each of us would’ve thought the others were crazy.
In fact, before Poker Club began, I barely knew Beau or Theo. We’re all represented by the same agent, Ethan West, so we’d see each other occasionally at functions or events. But being that we all play different sports, it’s not like we saw each other regularly enough to strike up friendships.
Until Ethan volunteered the three of us to judge a pie baking contest together. Normally, I could use Adalyn to get out of things like that, but the only thing my kid loves more than candy is pies. And Ethan knew it. Used my own kid against me.
So I sucked it up and did my good deed and served as a judge. I still to this day insist the caramel peach pie should’ve won—and I know Theo and Beau were also team peach—but when it came down to it, I couldn’t believe I was wasting my day arguing over pie. I turned in my vote and stormed off.
I didn’t expect to see Theo or Beau until the next dinner or gala Ethan forced us to attend. Little did I know, the two of them were plotting behind the scenes, discussing starting a get together around a hobby none of us knew we all shared until pie day.
Baked goods.
When the two of them got a hold of me and told me their idea, I thought they were fucking with me. But they laid it all out, and the more they talked, the more it made sense.
Beau genuinely loves baking. It’s part of the reason he opened Sugar and Sweets with his sister, Gabi. He might be the money behind the business, but that doesn’t mean he doesn’t like to dabble from time to time—though Gabi doesn’t know he does, and neither does his wife, Shelby.
For Theo, it serves as a way to unplug from a hellish baseball schedule. The baseball season makes the hockey calendar look like a walk in the park. He didn’t know a ton about baking before we started this, but he was a big fan of the British baking competitions and is insistent that we figure out how to make the perfect macaron.
We can’t. Those fuckers are impossible to nail down.
As for me, I was hesitant at first. Which came as a shock to literally no one. Beau and Theo figured it was because of my normal reasons—hockey life is busy and I’m a widowed, single father who feels guilty about leaving my daughter with a sitter, or my mother, on another night when I don’t have to.
Little did they know my reasoning was much deeper than that.
The real reason I turned down the initial invitation? I was convinced baking was going to hurt too bad.
Baking is what Hailey and I did together. It started with boxed brownies when we were two broke college kids living in our first apartment together. After a while, it became our thing. Brownies. Cookies. Muffins. It was our date night. Our way of just spending time together away from school, classes, practices…whatever was stressing us out at the time.
After she died, I couldn’t even look at a box of brownies for a year. I avoided that aisle in the grocery store like the plague. But I missed it. As much as I started doing it because she asked me to, I really did start enjoying it. I was confident that trying to bake again would just make me miss her that much more. And lord knows I did enough of that every day.
So when Beau and Theo approached me about this secret club, even though part of me really wanted to say yes, I turned them down.
But then one night, as I was sitting on the couch while Adalyn played with something on the floor, I swore I could hear Hailey’s voice. She was asking me why I was being a sad sack when I could be making our favorite brownies. Or making Adalyn her mother’s favorite sugar cookies.
I’ve rarely cried in front of my daughter, but that night she was five seconds away from seeing me break down.
I held it together as long as I could, but after I got Adalyn into bed, I sat on the bathroom floor and bawled my eyes out. I was a blubbering mess, unable to reconcile what the hell was going on in my head. I don’t believe in ghosts or the afterlife or any of that shit, but that night? I don’t know what happened. It was like Hailey was sitting next to me, telling me to start living my life again. And it was going to start with baking.
The next morning, I woke up and told Theo and Beau I was in. Because yes, it would make me miss her, but at the same time, it’s a part of her I could hold onto while also doing something for myself.
I did have one condition—it couldn’t be called a baking club. We had to come up with another name for it. I didn’t want to tell whoever was watching Adalyn that I was going baking.
Poker seemed to fit. Nobody would question that. Just a bunch of guys getting together to play cards. Totally normal. And not something I would ever have to offer an explanation for.
Beau owns the place, so he orders ingredients for us so we don’t use Gabi’s. Maddox, our most recent member, always makes sure his fiancée is occupied for the night so she doesn’t make any impromptu visits.
It’s perfect. It’s secret. It’s just for us. And we each leave with a tasty dessert at the end.
“I gotta say I was pleasantly surprised to get that text message from you today,” Theo says. “I figured with the playoffs we wouldn’t hear from you until you guys were out.”
“Can’t a guy just want to unplug for a minute and bake?” I ask as I start cracking my eggs.
“A guy can,” Maddox says. “You in particular being the guy…doesn’t.”
He’s not wrong, but I choose to ignore that statement. “It's just been a minute since we've all gotten together and I noticed that our schedules lined up. Figured, why not?”