Page 175 of Unlikely Pair

Page List

Font Size:

I look over to where Beau is motioning to see Theo, Liam, and Finn all talking around the dessert table. “Watch the grill for me? I need to make sure those three aren’t plotting to set off fireworks in my backyard.”

Beau laughs and takes the tongs out of my hand as I make my way over. “What are you three talking about?”

As far as I know, Liam, Finn, and Theo have never really spoken. Maybe a couple of words at the few events they’ve crossed paths at over the years, but whatever they’re talking about has the hairs on the back of my neck sticking up.

“Your teammates were just talking about how good the cupcakes are,” Theo says. “That they’ve never tasted cupcakes as good as these.”

Theo’s doing a horrible job of signaling that the cupcakes he’s talking about are the ones he made at Poker Club the other night. Once Sutton and I decided to throw this shindig, I told her I’d take care of the desserts if she handled going to the grocery store for the rest of the food. Which meant our entire baking night was an assembly line to get ready for today. My famous sugar cookies. Cake pops. Brownies. Maddox got a little crazy and whipped up some blondies. Beau had some starter ready to go so he made and brought a pepperoni pizza loaf for an appetizer. Theo didn’t even attempt his macarons, instead choosing to take on the cupcakes.

“I bet they’re good cupcakes.” I’m trying to keep an even face, but I don’t know what Theo’s up to. Does he want to tell them? That breaks Poker Club code. “I’ll have to try one.”

“Excuse me, guys,” Theo says, grabbing me by the arm and pulling me aside. “What are you doing?”

“Same can be asked of you? Were you about to tell them you made the cupcakes?”

“I don’t know? Maybe?” Theo looks back to Liam and Finn, who are in awe that the cupcakes they’re eating have a strawberry filling. “Maybe they’d want to join us?”

“Join us!” I say a little too loudly before going back to a whisper. “The club is for the four of us. I don’t even know if they like to bake.”

“We never said we’d never expand,” Theo says. “Plus, they seem like cool guys. And even if they don’t bake, I feel like they’d add to the vibe.”

I feel like there’s something more to this than just some new blood in the bakery. Then, as if I’m smacked over the head with it, I see Beau and Shelby bickering before she rolls her eyes and he kisses her. Not far from them are Maddox and Gabi, fussing over baby Ace. Sutton is putting out the food with Adalyn “helping” her the best she can.

Fuck. We all have someone to go home to. Someone to bake for. And then there’s Theo.

“Is it because you’re the only single guy in the group? I’m not teasing you if it is, just an honest question.”

He just shrugs, shoving his hands into the pocket of his shorts. “Is it so bad if it is?”

I hate this for him. The man is about to watch the love of his life marry another guy. And he’ll be standing next to her. I can’t imagine that feeling.

“If Maddox and Beau are okay with it, I’m fine,” I say. “But we can’t tell them what it is until we know they’re in and they can keep the secret.”

Theo holds up two fingers in scout’s honor. “I’ll gently approach them and see what they say.”

“Smart move,” I say, patting him on the back. “And hey. Whenever you need to talk, you know I’m here, right?”

Theo doesn’t say anything, and Maddox and Beau filter over, making sure everything’s okay. I quickly fill them in.

“Theo is wondering if we can invite Liam and Finn into the Poker Club because he doesn’t want to be the only single guy.”

“Hey. You said you weren’t going to make fun of me.”

“Can’t make fun of the truth,” I say.

“I mean, I don’t mind them,” Maddox says. “Or…there’s another idea.”

Theo gives him a questioning look. “What’s that?”

Beau just shakes his head before answering. “You could go to Ellie right now, tell her how you feel, and not be the only single guy.”

Theo starts to rebut, but shuts it down. I don’t know what he was going to say, but there’s something I need to tell him. Something he needs to hear.

“You know she’s going to marry him, right? If she doesn’t know how you feel, that you’re crazy about her, and that she’s a hell of a lot more than your best friend, she’s going to marry him.”

“And then what happens?” Beau adds. “You’re going to be miserable for the rest of your life? Try to date but nothing ever feels right because she’s not Ellie? Keep doing what you’ve been doing?”

“That’s not why my dates haven’t worked out,” Theo defends.


Novels you may like ...