I had the sudden, strong certainty that this was a terrible plan. That I would die here, at the hands of the brother of the man I’d killed. There was a certain kind of poetic justice to that. The only problem was that I didn’t want to die. I’d just realized I had a life worth living; I didn’t want it to end now.
My fingers closed around the edge of the screen door, flaps of ripped screening shivering as I opened it. The handle of the main door creaked as I pressed the lever and stepped inside.
My eyes needed no time to adjust, since it had been so dark outside. I stood on old floorboards, surrounded by peeling red wallpaper. An ornate staircase led up to the second floor, with a narrow hallway to its left. To my right, a parlor awaited. Its fireplace whistled softly with each gust of wind. Old rugs and moth-eaten furniture gave the place a musty, dank smell. The scent of rot permeated the air.
“Hello?” I called out. I wasn’t supposed to be sneaking in; Enzo’s attention had to be on me.
The house creaked in response. Mouth dry, I stepped forward, peeking into the parlor and seeing nothing but dust and old furniture. Not wanting to go upstairs, I ducked around and walked along the wood-paneled hallway. My heart had jammed itself in my throat. My legs prickled, and I strained to hear something—anything—that would warn me of what was to come.
The steady drip-drip-drip of a leaking tap echoed toward me from the back of the house, but I didn’t reach it. Instead, I stopped in front of wooden double doors that opened onto a large, formal living room. The doors were inlaid with stained glass, reflecting the dim light within.
Enzo sat in a wingback chair, darkness cutting across his weaselly features. His eyes were shadowed, but his thin lips curled into a cruel smile. “You came. I didn’t think you would.”
Too soon. I wasn’t supposed to find him so quickly. Was everyone in position? I couldn’t risk speaking into my earpiece, and I didn’t know if they could hear Enzo over the sound of the wind and the groaning house.
“Enzo,” I said, and it sounded loud and forced, but I wanted the rest of the team to know what was happening. I stepped across the threshold just as a shadow moved behind me. The floor creaked as Sally cut off my retreat.
Keeping my arms by my sides, I tried to focus on the man in front of me while keeping my panic at bay. He unfolded his long body to stand, wincing slightly. He had a black eye and a cut on his cheekbone, probably from the tumble off the roof of my bakery awning. Behind me, Sally shifted his bulk, making the old floorboards creak again.
To my right, another fireplace loomed like a black hole. Its mantel was heavy marble, with a matching marble surround rising out of the floorboards. The iron grate was still in place, along with age-old ashes beneath it. There was an ornate, round side table beside a faded sofa, and a stack of old newspapers in the corner. The light in the chandelier flickered overhead, too dim to really do much except make the shadows dance.
I wanted to run. Coming here had been a mistake. They’d kill me before Knox even got through the back door.
“Give me the gun.” Enzo extended a hand, and I saw a splint on his index and middle fingers. Another relic of his fall, I supposed.
“I need your assurance that you’ll leave me alone.”
“Sure, I’ll leave you alone, Ellie.” His smile was a slash of white in the darkness. I didn’t trust it for a second.
“You’ll leave Marswood Harbor and never come back.”
“That, I can definitely promise. This shithole will never see me again.”
“Good,” I said. “Good.”
There was a creak. The wind? Or something else? Sally? One of Knox’s brothers?
“The gun, Ellie.”
“I go by Caroline now.”
“I don’t give a shit!” he shouted, making me jerk. My heart rate spiked as Enzo approached with a snarl on his face.
Now was my time to act. I had to do it now, before he hurt me. But was it too soon? Had Knox gotten into position? Were reinforcements on the way?
The plan had seemed so simple when he’d explained it to me, but now that I was surrounded by these men who wanted me dead, I felt so very vulnerable.
In the depths of my soul, an old, familiar creature stretched its sleepy muscles. Over seven years ago, it had risen up inside me and helped me through the most awful night of my life. It had created the most awful night of my life.
The monster inside me wanted blood. It wanted to put Enzo in the ground so he would never threaten me or my family or my town again.
“Where is it?” He took another step toward me. “My idiot brother should have gotten rid of that gun when Dad told him to. Come to think of it, Dad should have gotten me to get rid of it. But he always trusted Tony, didn’t he? I was just the fuckup. The backup. The one who came in to fix everyone else’s messes because I wasn’t afraid of getting my precious hands dirty.” He smiled at me. “Maybe I should be thanking you for getting Tony out of my way, but then again, my father still never trusted me with his empire once my brother was gone. So all you did was cause everything…to…fall…apart!”
He lunged.
Panic gripped my body and froze my muscles. Too late, I clawed at my waistband. I brushed the edge of hard plastic when Enzo’s hand connected with my throat. He gripped hard as I gurgled, gasping, clawing.
Finally, my fingers closed around what I needed as Enzo brought his face close to mine. His breath smelled of onions.