But if she kept pushing me away, where did that leave me?
If she didn’t trust me to take care of her, maybe that meant she didn’t trust me at all. Maybe she’d be like everyone else, hiding the truth and blindsiding me with it when it was most convenient for her.
Tilting my head up toward the spray, I washed away the bitter thoughts and refocused on what mattered.
Get rid of Enzo. Protect Caroline.
Everything else could wait.
TWENTY
CAROLINE
The plan for the day was to deal with the skunk smell and try to get the bakery operational again. As we drove from Knox’s house toward town, I clasped my hands in my lap and tried to pretend I wasn’t full to the brim with anxiety.
“Maybe it’s karma,” I said.
Knox wore a black beanie with a quilted tan jacket and faded jeans. He was utterly relaxed behind the wheel of his car, flicking a glance over at me before saying, “What is?”
“My place getting destroyed. The bakery being trashed. It’s karma for what I did.” As was experiencing the closeness and bliss I’d felt with Knox last night, and then immediately getting a reminder from Etta Mars that I would never be worthy of her grandson. He had a beautiful Harvard Law graduate waiting to walk down the aisle toward him.
He was silent for a beat, then slowed the car and pulled over on the shoulder. There were tall pine trees on either side of us, their needles dusted with snow. The naked branches of bare deciduous trees poked out between them, waiting for the warmth of spring. I felt as frozen as the land. Knox kept the car running as he put the hazard lights on and pulled the handbrake. Then he looked at me. “Explain that to me.”
I frowned. “Explain what?”
“Explain how saving your sister’s life means you can’t live your own.”
My throat tightened like Tony Costa’s ghost had both hands around my neck from beyond the grave. I swallowed. “I took his life, Knox. That’s evil.”
“Evil is putting your hands on a woman. Evil is abusing the mother of your child. Evil is doing any number of things that don’t include rushing to a loved one’s defense. You’re not evil.”
My eyes were full of tears. “How can you say that when you know the truth? I wanted him to die, Knox. It might have been the corner of the fireplace that took him out, but there was intent behind my push. And if that hadn’t killed him, I would’ve found another way.”
“And if he hadn’t been attacking your sister, would you have attacked him?”
I blinked. “Well…no.”
He slid his hand over my jaw and pressed his forehead to mine. “So you’re not evil, Caroline.”
I huffed, embarrassed by the tear sliding down my cheek. “It’s that simple, huh.”
“It’s that simple.” He pressed a kiss to my forehead, then straightened, put the car in gear, and started driving again.
I sat beside him, staring out the window and seeing nothing. I desperately wanted to believe him but couldn’t quite bring myself to do it. I was so deeply ashamed of what I’d done—of what I’d felt in that moment. I was afraid of what was inside me.
What if the next time I felt threatened, I snapped? What if it wasn’t just threat that would make me react this way, but anger, shame, or heartbreak? How could I be absolutely sure that I hadn’t taken the first step onto a very slippery slope?
We turned onto the road that would carry us into town. The toxic mix of self-hatred and shame inside me caused my mouth to open and words to come out before I could think better of it. “Are you going to call her?”
“Who?” Knox asked, slowing as he hit the busier part of town. Although, with Marswood Harbor, “busy” was relative.
“Greta.”
“Who’s Greta?”
“Your perfect match!” I clicked my tongue. He hadn’t even opened the folder his grandmother had left? Not when I’d gotten into the shower or gotten dressed? Not in all the time he was in the kitchen on his own? I’d waited all of three seconds to take a peek!
Yet more evidence that I was a bad person, no? Or at least a very petty one.