He huffed a laugh. “So you know my history as well as I know yours.”
“Hardly. I know your mom left you, your dad, and your brothers when you were young. And I know your dad passed when you were a teenager. You told me that part, that day on the beach.”
His lips tightened slightly, and he nodded. “When my mom left, no one told me what was going on. I was only six years old. I guess they thought they were protecting me, but I knew something was wrong. It was confusing and—and terrifying.” He grimaced. “And then the same thing happened with my dad. I was fifteen when he got cancer, and he hid it from everyone. Made Gideon promise not to tell the rest of us until it was too late. I was completely blindsided.”
People had kept secrets from him when it mattered—even if they’d thought they were doing him a kindness—and it had led to the two biggest losses of his life. The shock must have been immense. The wounds had shaped the man he was today.
“I decided that no one would ever blindside me again as long as I could help it,” Knox said. His jaw tightened, a muscle feathering in his cheek. “So I gather information. I make sure I know what’s going on in my town.”
My heart ached for him. Unable to stop myself, I reached across the table and put my hand over his. I felt like a hypocrite for wanting to comfort him, because wasn’t I just as bad as both his parents? As all the people who had kept those secrets from a younger, more vulnerable Knox? But as he sat across from me, immovable and huge and strong, I saw the soft heart of him, and I ached for the boy he’d been.
I knew what it was like to have to pretend to be strong when my insides were just one big ache.
“I’m so sorry,” I whispered.
He shifted his hand to stroke the side of mine with his thumb. The calluses on his finger scraped against my skin, sending shivers up my arm. He was warmer than me, his hand bigger. It felt so good to touch him. Too good.
I pulled my hand away, and he let me.
“Did you ever…” I cleared my throat. “Did you ever look for her? Your mom?”
He shrugged. “Yeah. Off and on for about a decade. Never found more than a trace. I found out she started going by her middle name—Viola—but that’s all I ever found. Drove me crazy until I decided she wasn’t worth my time. She left. Why would I care where she ended up?”
His words were casual, but there was a world of pain behind them. The yearning of a little boy for his mother. The ache of a teenager who felt abandoned. The determination of a grown man wanting to put things behind him.
A pit opened up in my stomach.
Knox watched me fuss with my hair and rearrange my clothes, all my nervous energy pouring out in jerky movements. He was still, cataloguing my reaction to tuck away with all the rest of my secrets. Then, in a deep, serious voice, he said, “I didn’t run you out of town because you made the best damn donut I’d ever tasted. And from what I’d read in his criminal record, Tony Costa seemed like a piece of shit who deserved what he got.”
Something pulled tight behind my ribs, and my eyes began to prickle. I didn’t understand my reaction to his words. Didn’t know why they made me want to cry. Was it because I agreed with him? Or because I was terrified he was wrong?
I didn’t want to be a murderer. I didn’t want to have someone’s death on my conscience, even if he was a piece of shit who deserved it. I didn’t want to know that I was capable of wishing someone dead and then seeing it through. But what was the alternative? Let him take my sister’s life? My unborn nephew’s?
Any way I looked at it, I was glad things had happened the way they did. I was glad Tony was dead, and that in itself made me feel like a monster. Never mind the fact that I was the one who’d done it.
“He did deserve to die,” I whispered, staring at the top of the table between us. “I just wish I hadn’t been the one to do it.”
It was only the splash of a tear against the fabric of my pants that made me realize I was crying. Horrified, I brushed at my face with my hands and made unintelligible noises that sounded dangerously close to sobs.
And then there was warmth.
I was on my feet with Knox’s arms around me, his body wrapped around mine like a protective cocoon. He held me, all heat and strength, without saying a word. I sobbed against his chest as the pain inside me bubbled over. Squeezing my eyes shut, I sucked in deep breaths to try to regain control over myself. Again. Twice today, he’d held me like this. Held me together as I fell apart. Knox’s hand made long, slow sweeps over my spine, and I inhaled the scent of his laundry detergent as I shoved my face in his shirt. I could feel the prickle of his chest hair through the fabric, and I wished I could mash my face against his bare skin.
When my breathing had settled, Knox swept a hand over my jaw and tilted my head up. His voice was calm when he said, “You’re not a bad person, Caroline.”
My chin wobbled. “How do you know?” I whispered.
His face softened, and his thumb made a slow sweep along the underside of my cheekbone. “Because I know the secrets of nearly every person in this town, and yours isn’t even close to the worst one. You did what you had to do so your sister could be free.”
My vision blurred again. “You’re making me cry,” I accused. “I hate you so much.”
He huffed, the breath ruffling my hair. I could hear the smile in his voice, even though I was staring at the buttons on his polo. “And you’re ruining my shirt with your snot and tears,” he rumbled, “but you don’t hear me complaining about it.”
I growled and shoved at him, which made him laugh as he caught my wrist and hauled me close again. His eyes sparkled as they softened. No one had ever looked at me like that before. Like I was the most special, most precious person they’d ever known.
“Knox…”
His lips tugged. “I know. Me too,” he rasped, and dipped his head toward me.