“You may. I may not answer, though.”
Her eyes narrowed ever so slightly, lips pursing.
I smiled at her. “Have a nice day!”
“You’re the best baker in town,” she continued, ignoring my dismissal.
“Technically, I’m the only baker in town.”
“Yes, but you’re the best in the county.”
“You could’ve led with that. It might’ve buttered me up enough to change my mind.” I smiled at her, knowing my eyes remained sharp and humorless. “Then again, it might’ve not.”
“I want you to make the cake.”
“You know, Marnie, sometimes, in life, we don’t get everything we want.” That was a lesson I’d learned often and thoroughly. “Good luck on your search.” And good luck to Bennett with whatever the hell was going on with her.
“I want to know why you’re refusing.”
“What you want is of no concern to me.”
“You’re being rude.”
“I would say that I’m simply stating a boundary. If you find that rude, I would invite you to introspect and figure out why that is.” My smile was beginning to ache, and I felt it turn to something sharper on my lips. “But I can be rude if you prefer.”
The two Mars men were silent, their heads bouncing between us like they were watching a tennis Grand Slam. They were both still looking at me when that flash went across her eyes again. It wasn’t hostile, exactly. It was more like she was holding a fishing rod and she’d just felt a nibble on the end of her hook. Like I’d caught her attention, and now she wanted to reel me in, wrench me gasping and failing out of the water, and figure out exactly what I was.
Fear scraped a hollow void in the pit of my stomach. I wanted her out. I wanted all three of them out. I pointed to the door and turned my attention to the bigger threat. Knox met my glare for a moment, then lifted his hands in surrender. He exchanged a glance with Bennett, tilting his head toward the door. I stood rooted to the spot, watching them until they exited the bakery and turned out of view of the big plate-glass windows. Then I exhaled, slumping against the counter, and closed my eyes.
Crap. Crap, crap, crap.
I’d come to Marswood Harbor because it was the one place on this earth I’d thought was safe. I’d been running from bad people for over three years, and this place was my last resort. It was a dying town that no one would ever move to. Somewhere no one would look for me. Off-limits to the men who had wanted to find me and dismember me, which meant I could fly in under the radar and stay here. A little haven where I could hide and rebuild after the night that had ruined my life—and saved my sister’s.
The memory of that night tried to claw its way up to the surface, and I shoved it back down with merciless, iron will. I would not think about that now, when there were people watching my every reaction. Even after seven and a half years, the memory was right there, ready to paint itself in gory red against the backs of my eyelids. Instead of indulging it, I turned to my old friend anger and wrapped my arms around it to keep it close.
Right now, I was angry at Etta Mars. She’d put us on the map. She’d come up with this stupid wedding scheme, and now we were inundated with people and press and attention.
I scanned the inside of the bakery I’d poured my heart into for four and a half long years. The four walls that had always felt safe.
I wondered if I’d gotten too comfortable, and if it was time for me to pack up and run.
KNOX
I could still taste the cinnamon sugar on my tongue as I got into my SUV. I’d parked across the street from Knead More Bread, and I watched Caroline through the windows as she moved around her business.
I’d expected her to refuse to make Bennett’s cake. I understood why: She found me threatening, and she wanted nothing to do with me. But I’d still asked, because I liked seeing the flush on her cheeks that told me I’d gotten to her. I liked knowing she understood the fact that I would never leave her alone.
Her past could come back and bite her at any time, and when it did, it would happen in Marswood Harbor. My town. My home.
A threat to my town was a threat to me. I didn’t tolerate being blindsided. Not ever again.
TWO
CAROLINE
FOUR YEARS AND EIGHT MONTHS AGO
Three days before The Incident With Knox Mars