Page 42 of Perfectly Average

Page List

Font Size:

Saturday evening snuck up on me while I was busy all week fixing some small, mostly cosmetic things in the living room, kitchen, and dining room in preparation for the guys coming over.

Lasagna is in the oven to stay warm, and all the side dishes are ready to go. In the fridge chilling, I have the local microbrewery craft mead the guys were drinking at the pool party.

I pop into the downstairs bathroom to check my hair and makeup and make sure I don’t have food stains dripping down my front. I’ve done it before when I’m in the zone and cooking. Not that I usually put together meals this elaborate.

Satisfied with my appearance, I check my phone and watch as the clock turns to six.

Knock knock.

Wow, talk about punctuality. Hope and excitement stir in my chest like butterflies when I realize how they go out of their way to show up for me.

“Coming!” I take a few calming breaths and consciously slow my need to rush to the door. I don’t think I’ve ever felt this drawn to anyone, and I’ve hit the jackpot with three handsome, considerate men. Real men who treat a woman with respect and kindness.

I swing open the door, and my jaw drops. They’re all polished up in dress shirts and slacks. Zeke is just a bit more dressy than his norm. Silas is rocking a dark and mysterious look with an all-black ensemble of a button-up shirt and sleek slacks. Even Mr. Casual Conrad has on real shoes instead of sandals.

It’s like a champagne cork pops open in my head, making me all fizzy inside.

They’re dressed up for me.

Conrad bites his lip, and I know he’s dying to tease me. Instead, he drags his long fingers through his blond locks and clears his throat.

I snap my gaping mouth closed. “Welcome to my humble abode!”

Ugh, did I just say that? I’m such a dork.

I chide myself for being so nervous, but it suddenly feels like tonight is the beginning of something wonderful in my life. Maybe it’ll only be a lust-filled fling, or maybe it could lead to something more. Do I dare even hope for that?

“You sure you don’t need us to fix your doorbell? We’d be happy to do that for you,” Zeke offers as I wave them in.

“That’s okay. I don’t know if I want solicitors bugging me,” I joke, sidestepping the idea since they likely wouldn’t let me pay, and I don’t want them to think I’m using them for their handyman skills.

From behind his back, Silas reveals two small flowering plants in pretty pots. “A hostess gift.”

Of course he wouldn’t bring me cut flowers, the gesture melts my heart. “I love them! And I forgot to get a pretty center piece for the table. They’re perfect. One second.” I accept Sila’s thoughtful gifts and rush to place them on the dining table and hurry back.

Zeke holds the baking tray, now refilled with fresh cookies they’ve made. Conrad has a bottle of liquor in his hands, extended for me.

“What’s this? More gifts?” I place a hand over my chest. “You guys are too generous. Come with me, and I’ll give you an abridged tour of the place.” I take the bottle and cookies and lead them to the kitchen.

As I’m about to set the bottle down on the counter, I glance at it and bark out a laugh. “Malört?”

“Malört for m’lady,” Conrad says with a deep bow, speaking with a faux British accent.

“Um, why?” I ask. This has to be one of the most intriguingly horrible liqueurs known to humankind.

“When I asked the saleslady at the liquor store for something special from your hometown, Chicago, she said it was a unique concoction…” Zeke starts to sound unsure of his purchase.

“She didn’t mention how it tastes?” I smirk.

“No, but she had that same strange look you do.”

“Well, its own company even leans into how ridiculous it tastes. One slogan says, ‘For when you want to unfriend someone… in person.’”

“Oh, god.” Zeke grimaces and palms his face in embarrassment. “We’re sorry.”

Silas reaches out to take back the bottle. “That’s not what we want.”

I touch his arm and smile gently. “I know. It’s actually very thoughtful and I love that. And once you have it, you’ll never forget it.”


Novels you may like ...