"She is. Completely chaotic — shows up with dirt under her nails and six ideas she had in the car — but her eye is unreal. The two of us on a gala build are a nightmare for everyone else because we lose track of time and suddenly it's four a.m. and we're arguing about stem angles."
Gemma grinned. "I need to meet her."
"You'd like her. Everyone likes Lily. She's impossible not to like."
She asked about how I'd gotten into event design. I told her the short version — hospitality degree, entry-level work at a hotel, a catering company, then the Sterling Club listing I'd applied to three times before Lola gave me a shot.
I didn't tell her the long version. The one that started with a fifteen-year-old rearranging the living room furniture because her mother was asleep and the apartment felt wrong and she'd discovered that changing a room could change how it felt to be inside it.
She told me about architecture. The buildings she loved — weird ones, angular ones, the ones everyone walked past without looking at. She was working on a community center in the Bronx. Affordable housing with actual design thought behind it. "Everyone deserves a beautiful space," she said. Her eyes lit up when she talked about it, and I thought: whoever raised this woman did something right.
She reminded me of someone. The way she leaned forward when she was interested. The careful way she listened. I kept almost placing it and losing it.
"I work with a nonprofit that does community space design," she said. "Parks, public gardens, gathering spaces. We should talk about what you could do with an outdoor installation. Seriously. Your eye is wasted on table arrangements."
Something in my chest warmed. Recognition. The feeling of someone seeing your work and understanding what it actually was, beyond what it looked like. James did that — in the forbidden hours, in the quiet of the club, he watched me work and understood I wasn't decorating. I was building atmospheres.
Gemma saw the same thing, and she'd known me eight days.
"I'd like that," I said. "The outdoor thing. Let's talk."
She grinned. Wide, easy. Gap between her front teeth that made her look younger than she was. "I like you. You're not what I expected from a Sterling Club person."
"What did you expect?"
"Intimidating. Snobby. Velvet ropes and raised eyebrows."
"I'm deeply intimidating."
"You're five-four and you have coffee foam on your nose."
I wiped my nose. She laughed. I laughed. And for forty-five minutes I sat in a coffee shop with a woman who felt like a real friend — not a work friend, not a proximity friend — and I didn't think about James or the investigation or the distance I was trying not to feel.
When I got back to the club, I had a text:
Gemma: Same time Thursday? I'll bring you a hard hat. For your intimidating brand.
I saved her number under "Gemma" with a cactus emoji because she'd told me she kept killing her office plants and had given up on everything except cacti.
* * *
He came back on Thursday.
He'd been at the club every night — still staying, still present. But something had closed behind his eyes since the gala. A half-second delay before every sentence, like a man running his words through a filter. I'd felt it. He knew I'd felt it. Four days of neither of us naming it.
Thursday night. Private cocktail reception, fifty members, low-key. I had the flowers cleared and the candles boxed by ten-thirty. He was in his booth. The last member had left twenty minutes ago.
I was resetting the bar display when he appeared beside me. Close. Closer than he'd been all week — close enough that I could smell him, wool and coffee and clean skin, and my stupid body reacted before my brain could intervene. Four days of distance and he still smelled like safety. I hated that.
"I need to tell you something," he said.
My hands stopped. Here it comes. The speech. I'd been rehearsing my response for four days — calm, practical, no tears, a clean exit. I had it ready. I had everything ready. That was my whole personality.
"Okay."
"I pulled away." He said it like a man reading a verdict. "After the gala. You felt it. I know you felt it because you took the toothbrush back and you stopped texting first, and I noticed, and I should have said something then."
He'd noticed the toothbrush. Of course he had.