Page 97 of Found Hearts

Page List

Font Size:

“I have no clue,” Eli starts, but a knock comes on the door, and because of everything that’s happened, I feel my heart begin to race.

I’m so scared this is only going to get worse, and eventually Eli will get sick of it, sending me packing. If I were him, I would, only to keep Mason safe, and I keep thinking I should just move back in with Lacey and Jonah, so Eli doesn’t have to deal with this.

“Babe,” Eli murmurs sweetly. “It’s okay. I’m sure Aunt Sally just sent up some breakfast. She’s like that.”

He gets up from the bed, walking over to my side. He runs a soothing hand over my hair, leaning down to kiss where he just touched. Taking Mason from my lap, he heads toward the door.

Eli was right.

A cart with several covered plates is pushed into the small sitting area, and with Mason held against his bare chest, Eli swings a hand toward the cart.

“See, just some breakfast,” Eli chides, winking at me.

“Breakfast is much better.”

After we’ve eaten and thanked Sally, the three of us are on the way back home. We’ve talked about reporting things to the police, but I don’t want to drag Mason around with us.

Eli is going to stay with him, and Lacey is going to come with me to the police station, but first I need to get together the notes we’ve been keeping on Madeline.

I’m just hoping her arrest knocked some sense into her and she’s heading back home, but when we pull up to the house, that’s not what’s happening.

“Fuck,” Eli mutters, dragging a hand through his hair, and I feel like I’m going to throw up. I start crying the second my brain processes what is unfolding in front of us.

The screens on the porch are slashed, there are broken surfboards in the front yard, but the worst part is the smashed front window. A giant hole sits where the window used to be, and I don’t even want to go inside to assess the damage.

“Guess the police didn’t drive by like they said, and she was obviously let out after she was arrested,” Eli says, but it’s difficult to hear him over my sobs.

I can’t even think straight, but no matter what Eli says, I have to go. Staying here is putting him and Mason at risk, and I’m done worrying that something is going to happen to them.

“Eli, I can’t be here, and you know that. You have to put Mason’s safety first,” I manage, my tears falling fast and hard.

There are many times in my life that I wish I could go back in time and change things, but this takes the cake. I’d go back and never have an affair because despite leaving school, starting my life over in Hawaii, and having zero contact with Madeline’s husband, she’s still making my life a living hell.

“Wait in the car,” Eli demands, not acknowledging my words. “Stay here with Mason.”

He’s firm, hitting me with an anger-filled stare, and I nod gently, knowing not to argue with him at this point.

But as he’s walking up to the house, a police car pulls in the driveway, parking behind Eli’s car.

Two officers exit the car and Eli meets them halfway, the anger still apparent on his face. He’s so over this and so am I, but he wouldn’t be dealing with this if it wasn’t for me.

I step out of the car, opening the back door to take Mason’s car seat out. He’s asleep, his sweet little face calm and quiet, unaware of the chaos.

“You Eli Hamilton?” one of the officers asks.

“Yeah. What the hell is going on?”

“A neighbor reported a disturbance, and we arrested a woman just a little while ago. We’re holding her at the station as she was just⁠—”

I immediately cut them off, my words coming out fast and concerned. “Is her name Madeline?”

The other officer pulls out a notepad, flipping a page or two before confirming an answer to my question.

“Yes, Madeline Albright-Waterson,” he says. “Do you know her?”

“Yes, we’ve been dealing with her for a while now, and things just keep escalating,” Eli tells them, as I swipe away the tears that have begun to dry on my cheeks. “And you just left my house like this? Open and trashed without⁠—”

Now it’s the officer who cuts in, holding up a hand to stop Eli from rightfully continuing to rant. I was thinking the same thing. They arrested Madeline and left his house with the window shattered, not bothering to try and contact Eli.


Novels you may like ...