“You ever think you’ll reach out to any of your friends from high school now that you’re back and things are settling down?”
“Huh?” I ask, waiting for him to repeat it.
“Your friends from high school,” he clarifies. “Will you see any of them?”
Eli’s friends are people he’s known basically his whole life. That’s kind of how this side of the island is with everyone knowing everyone. Being close with his cousin Owen led him to his friend group, but that’s not how Lacey and I are. Our dad ruined that for us.
“I don’t really have any friends from high school,” I admit, sounding like a loser. I don’t even have friends from college either.
Those eight months I was there, I made more enemies than friends, and while my roommate and I got along, we stopped talking after the shit hit the fan. I wouldn’t dare call or text her now. Her life has probably gone back to normal, and I’d hate to ruin that.
“It’s hard when your dad…” I trail off, knowing I don’t really need to explain things. “People weren’t particularly nice to me or Lacey either.”
“I’m sorry. That sucks. They’re missing out because you’re really fucking cool, Lena.” Eli hits me with that perfect smile, adding on a cute little wink, and I feel my cheeks heat up.
There’s something about him that makes me want to be close to him, to share stories and laugh. He feels safe and comfortable, and to me, that’s everything.
“Funny story about high school though, if you want to hear it before you head out,” I say, thinking back to when I was living with Jonah and Lacey was on tour. It still makes me laugh.
“Hit me with it.”
He stands up, moving over to take Mason out of his swing. Giving his belly a little tickle as he lifts him out and sits back down at the island, with Mason in his lap, his knee bouncing a little to keep him entertained.
It’s adorable and fuck me if it doesn’t make me want Eli more than I already do. I’ve never had baby fever or whatever women talk about, but seeing him with Mason makes my heart feel like it’s going to burst.
“So, I got asked out a lot because I think guys thought I was easy because of my dad. Somehow, I was a slut because my dad was a rocker and druggie. I don’t know, but I said yes to this one guy…”
“Just one?” Eli questions, laughing a little.
“Obviously not just one guy. There were others, but this guy was kinda popular and cute, and a bunch of girls were into him. You know, high school bullshit with girls and jealousy.”
“I don’t know anything about being jealous,” Eli quips, sarcasm lacing his words, and I let out a hearty laugh.
“You keep telling yourself that, dude,” I press back, both of us smiling. “I was living with Jonah at the time, and Lacey was on tour. So, the date sucked. The guy was a dick and literally asked me to blow him on the way to the restaurant. Why I continued on is beyond me.”
“Wait, he asked you to blow him in the car? Smooth move, dickhead. What did you say?” Eli asks, sounding astonished, and to tell you the truth, I should have been more taken aback than I was at the time.
“I laughed, stupidly, and said nothing. I just changed the subject, but I wish I would have been more like I am now and told him to go fuck himself.”
Lesson learned that men suck. Unfortunately, it didn’t come until after I slept with my professor and got kicked out of school.
“But that’s not the funny part,” I continue. “I was learning ASL because living with Jonah and making him read lips and write shit down was exhausting. I wasn’t great at it, and he asked me how the date went when I got home.”
“Oh fuck, I can’t wait to hear what you told him. The whole lost-in-translation thing, huh?” Eli has a huge smile on his face, and Mason has Eli’s finger in his mouth, gnawing away on it, reminding me that I need to find him some teethers.
“I tell him that the date sucked. That part I got right, but when he asked me why the date sucked, I told him that the guy ate my pussy when I was in the bathroom.”
Eli lets out a laugh, his head falling back, and when he looks at me, he shakes his head, his eyes wide, his mouth open in shock.
“You didn’t?” he questions with curiosity.
“I did, and Jonah was seriously looking at me like, what the fuck, and asked me to repeat myself. Which I did, the exact same way I did the first time.”
“What were you trying to tell him, because getting eaten out doesn’t sound like such a bad thing if it’s done right?” Eli teases. “Might know someone who does it pretty damn well.”
“Oh, you and your ego,” I joke, rolling my eyes. “He ate my pie while I was in the bathroom, and eventually we got there, but Jonah had to write down what I initially told him, and I’m sure you can imagine the embarrassment and the laughter.”
“That’s hilarious. Guessing you got better at signing then.”