He shakes his head, cutting me off. “No, I gotta learn to do this, right? I mean, if he’s mine.” He adds that last part in as an afterthought, but it’s also said with more conviction than I expect.
“Okay, so you just sit on the ball and bounce,” I say, helping him take Mason, adjusting his arms to hold him properly.
Sitting down, he begins to bounce, but I let out a stifled laugh. He’s moving like he’s about to launch Mason and himself through the ceiling.
“Softly, gently,” I instruct, resting my hands on his shoulders to slow him down. “This is not the gym during a third grade P.E. class. It’s supposed to be soothing, like it mimics the movement…”
I stop short of my explanation. I don’t know what’s a trigger for Eli, but I can’t imagine talking about how bouncing on the ball mimics the movement of the mother while the baby is in utero.
Looking up at me, he’s far more attractive than I realized. Deep brown eyes, stubble covers his chiseled jaw, and a perfectly sloped nose. He has a deep tan like most men on this island, spending so much time out in the sun or surfing.
He smells of the ocean and burnt wood, and I can’t help but wonder if that will be something Mason remembers about him too. It’s a unique smell, a smell that I will forever associate with Eli.
He reaches up and runs his thumb over the place I hit my eye, and I feel the warmth of his touch, leaning into it. There’s a comfort to it that I haven’t felt in so long.
“You’re going to want to put some ice on that,” he whispers, smiling a little, and he then looks down at Mason, who is now asleep in his arms.
“Holy shit, he’s asleep,” Eli now says, shock in his voice. “It actually worked. Now what?”
Still looking up at me, seeking guidance, I explain how to carefully place Mason back in the crib, and basically sneak out without stubbing a toe and hitting your head.
This comment elicits a chuckle from Eli, and I smile back at him as I close the door.
What a fucking night, but at least it seems to be ending well.
I wake to a ping from my phone, followed by another, then another, then another.
“Fuck,” I grumble, scrubbing a hand down my face as the other reaches for my phone on the nightstand. Blinking my eyes awake, I try to focus in the muted light of the room, the blackout blinds doing their job of keeping the sun out.
My phone pings again, the screen lighting up and practically blinding me. I blink again, the screen finally coming into focus as I see the messages from someone named Cindy flood my screen.
* * *
Cindy: Hey, remember me
Cindy: Been thinking about you.
Cindy: Last time was fun.
Cindy: I still think about what you did.
Cindy: Wanna hook up this weekend?
Cindy: Can make it worth your while...
* * *
I don’t even know what that last message means, or who this chick is. I don’t ever give my number out to my hook ups because I don’t want to create this illusion that I somehow want more. But they always seem to find me, either on Facebook or Instagram or hell, even just my phone number.
Cindy, it seems, has found me on Facebook. And isn’t shy about asking for what she wants, something I can totally get on board for.
Propping the pillows up behind me, I shuffle a little, so I’m leaning back against the headboard. Before answering, I do what any self-respecting guy like me would do and I open her profile, scrolling through her pictures, partly so I can remember who she is and partly to help me decide if I want a second round.
Smiling, the memories come back to me, a chick who goes to school on the mainland but whose family lives here. We hooked up about two weeks ago when she first got home and I won’t lie, it was fun.
Hot.
The kind of thing I would definitely...