Hey, I was a preteen with functioning eyes, and a girl could dream. Though I will never, ever admit that out loud, not even under magical interrogation.
Knowing who they were five years ago doesn’t mean I know them now, and it certainly doesn’t mean I want to pack my bags and move to Onyx Hollow because a mark appeared on my wrist out of nowhere. People change. I’ve changed. The puggy twelve-year-old is long gone, replaced by someone who’s learned to think for herself.
“You always knew you would eventually join them,” Mom says, her voice taking on that matter-of-fact tone that drives me absolutely crazy.
I stare at her because sometimes I genuinely wonder whether my mother hears herself when she talks. Does she realize how completely insane that sounds? How utterly presumptuous it is to assume I’d just go along with plans made before I was born?
“I have nothing in Onyx Hollow,” My voice rises, despite my efforts to stay calm.
Mom’s expression tightens, the lines around her eyes deepening. “This isn’t about Onyx Hollow, Bea.”
“Well, it certainly feels like it is,” I stomp my feet like a petulant child.
The gesture is embarrassing even as I do it, but I can’t seem to stop myself. Everything about this conversation makes me feel like I’m twelve again, powerless and frustrated and tired of being told what my life is supposed to look like.
My mother’s hands go to her hips in that universal gesture of parental exasperation, and I can almost see her counting to ten before she responds. “It’s about a promise, Bea. One our family has honored for generations, long before you or I were born. We don’t get to decide that a covenant no longer matters simply because honoring it has become inconvenient.”
Well, that rubs me the wrong way. Celeste Wyatt—I would never call my momma by her first name out loud, but I’m mad, so there—has always had a way of making things sound so simple when they’re anything but. To her, being a Wyatt means carrying what came before us, respecting the people who made it possible for our family to exist here in the first place, and making sure whatever they built survives long after we’re gone.
She sees it as a sacred trust, a responsibility passed down through generations like the family recipes or grandmother’s grimoire. Coven is family, family is tradition, tradition protects us all. That’s practically the Wyatt family motto.
I understand that philosophy, and I even respect it most of the time. There’s something beautiful about being part of something bigger than yourself, about knowing your place in a long line of strong women who built something worth preserving.
What I don’t understand is why respecting their choices means surrendering mine completely.
“I didn’t make that promise,” I huff, my stomach churns with anxiety and growing helplessness that makes me feel sick.
Her face softens immediately, which somehow makes me want to scream more than when she’s angry. At least anger I can fight against. This gentle understanding feels like being smothered with kindness.
“No, you didn’t,” she replies, and my Dad, of course, nods along with her like they’ve rehearsed this conversation.
“Then why am I responsible for keeping it?” I whine, hating how young I sound but unable to stop the words from tumbling out.
Her gaze drops to my wrist and mine follows automatically, like we’re both drawn to the evidence of my fate marked clearly on my skin. Five little claw marks stare back at me, as dark and permanent as the morning they first appeared. They’re not large, each one is maybe half an inch long, but they’re unmistakably there, unmistakably real, unmistakably mine whether I want them or not.
“Because sometimes we inherit more than our names and our magic,” she says softly, her voice carrying the weight of generations of Wyatt women who came before us.
I rub my thumb over the marks, already knowing they won’t disappear beneath my touch but unable to stop myself from trying. The skin there is slightly raised, like old scar tissue, though they’ve never hurt or bothered me physically. “That doesn’t mean I should have to inherit someone else’s life too.”
“Nobody is asking you to give up your life,” my father says with a sigh that sounds like it comes from somewhere deep in his chest.
“Aren’t you?” I look between them both, searching their faces for some sign that they understand what they’re really asking of me.
The question hangs between us, heavy and impossible to ignore, but I don’t see a way around any of this.
Kareem, Cassius, Idris, and Roman aren’t strangers, not really. Our families spent countless hours around one another before the Jaguars relocated. Holiday parties and coven meetings, community events and school functions, our lives were intertwined in the casual way that happens in small magical communities.
I was a stupid little girl with a stupid little crush on boys who were older, gorgeous, and mostly unaware that I existed beyond being ‘the Wyatt kid who was always around’.
I’m not that girl anymore, and they aren’t those boys. Five years changes people, shapes them into versions of themselves that might be completely different from who they used to be. I’ve grown up, figured out who I am when I’m not living in the shadow of family expectations. They’ve probably done the same. Whatever connection our families decided we should have doesn’t change that fundamental truth.
“What if I don’t want them?” I ask quietly, the words barely above a whisper.
Mom takes a breath, but I keep going before she can answer, before she can give me another speech about duty and tradition and the importance of honoring our ancestors.
“What if they don’t want me?”
That is the question nobody ever seems to ask, the elephant in the room that everyone pretends doesn’t exist. Everyone talks about the covenant as if it’s just automatic, as if five marks on my wrist guarantee happily ever after for all involved. As if desire and compatibility and actual human feelings don’t matter when magic and old promises are involved.