The extra beers had barely left her hands before Kayleigh squealed, “Do you have any idea who you were just talking to?”
Jo glanced over her shoulder again, but the guy from the bar was gone. When she turned back around, Kayleigh was beaming. She opened her mouth to say more, but then the overhead lights dimmed, and the room erupted in shouts and applause as the band crowded onto the small stage. The drummer and guitar player looked like sisters, both donning long, brown hair and deeply tanned skin.
But it was the lead singer Johanna couldn’t look away from.
There was something different about his presence now that he was on stage. He stood tall, shoulders thrown back, but everything about him radiated ease. His features looked almost contemplative as he pulled the microphone from its stand and scanned the crowd. The moment his gaze landed on Jo, heat burned from the roots of her hair to the tips of her toes. His grin widened at the sight of her, and to her horror, he pointed at her, causing dozens of heads to turn in her direction.
“This first song is for the girl whose name I will get out of her before the end of the night.”
Half of the crowd disappeared before the end of the set, but the half that remained was eating up every second of it. The music was a little too punk for Johanna’s taste, but she had to admit, the man knew how to work a crowd. Every few minutes, his eyes would find her again, and it momentarily pinned her to the spot. His skin glowed beneath the spotlights, and he had the type of contagious energy that immediately electrified the rest of the room. Even the people who didn’t know the lyrics were bouncing around, sweating and screaming and grinding against one another—Kayleigh being one of them. Despite herself, Jo found herself bobbing to the beat and letting Kayleigh rope her into her dancing. Miller mainly just stood there, but at least he was smiling.
Once the band finished their final song and the spotlights flickered off, the majority of the members headed for the bar, groups of fans trailing after them. Johanna’s mystery man, however, was nowhere to be seen.
Addie and Liv had already dipped out halfway through the set with the other boys, taking an Uber back to campus to catch some house party near their dorm. Johanna did another quick scan of the crowd.
“Should I order an Uber?” Miller suggested.
“No,” Kayleigh whined and stuck her lower lip out. She slung her arm over Jo’s shoulders, leaning more weight onto Jo than she’d expected, and they both stumbled to the side. “Not until Jo gives that guy her number.”
“I’m not giving anyone my number,” said Jo as she clung to Kayleigh’s arm, trying to keep them both upright.
“Well that’s a shame.”
She jumped at the deep voice behind her and whipped around.
The lead singer ran a hand through his hair, pushing it back from his face, his white T-shirt now clinging to his chest with sweat. “I don’t believe I had the chance to introduce myself before. I’m Greyson, but you can call me Grey.”
“Her name’s Johanna!” Kayleigh nearly cried out. “But she goes by Jo.”
Jo shot her a disbelieving look. Traitor.
“Johanna.” Grey smiled as he said it, like he liked the way her name tasted in his mouth. “Let me buy you a drink.”
“We were just leaving,” said Jo.
He was beautiful—she wasn’t oblivious. But he also looked like trouble, something Johanna was desperately trying to avoid. College was her fresh start. She wasn’t going to ruin that the very first week just because some guy in a band looked good in leather pants and had long eyelashes.
“Well,” said Kayleigh. “There’s a wait for an Uber anyway…”
Grey stepped forward, close enough that the earthy smell of him flooded her senses. He lifted a lock of her hair and twisted the curl around his fingers. She forced herself to keep a neutral expression, but her breath caught in her throat. “So what’ll it be, Johanna?” he murmured. “One beer?”
Jo pursed her lips and cast her gaze toward the long line of people waiting for a car on the sidewalk. “I’m going to go wait at that table over there.” She pointed to one of the bar tables near the door. “And if you can get one before the Uber gets here, then fine.”
Grey grinned, accepting the challenge, and wove back through the crowd toward the bar, shrugging off girls who threw their hands at him as he went. Kayleigh opened her mouth, but Jo held up a finger to stop her.
“Don’t. Say. Anything.”
“I’ll be by the bar,” Miller announced, and when Kayleigh hesitated by Jo’s side, he reached over, hooked his arm through Kayleigh’s elbow, and hauled her along with him. Jo sighed, ventured over toward the windows, and slid into one of the stools. The crowd started to thin as people filtered out the door, a few pausing just outside to smoke.
“Peace offering.”
Grey slid a beer across the table to Jo. The chatter of the bar and clamoring of equipment as the rest of the band packed up faded to the background as he came into focus. He braced his forearms on the narrow table and leaned forward, leaving barely a foot of space between their faces. He had blue eyes, Johanna realized. A detail she hadn’t noticed before.
She sipped the beer and raised her eyebrows.
“You don’t like it,” said Grey.
Jo took another sip and tilted her head to the side, considering. She wasn’t a fan of beer in general, but this one had a sort of citrusy aftertaste. She couldn’t decide how she felt about it. “It’s not bad.”