I start to push the door open wider and open my mouth to announce myself—
“You sure about not taking Willow home? You’ve been dating for what, like a year now?” comes Alan’s best friend Jake’s voice.
“Jesus, stop. What we have isn’t dating. It’s just her clinging cluelessly.”
I freeze. Alan’s words hit me like a sledgehammer over the sound of some football game. My grip on the presents tightens until the wrapping paper crinkles.
“What the fuck, bro? I thought you liked her.” I recognize Sean’s voice. “She’s so nice. And hot.” He’s probably the one responsible for leaving the door ajar.
“Well, duh. You think I’d put up with her if she was a bitch?” Alan scoffs. “But get this—last week she had the nerve to ask if I’d take her to spend Christmas with my family.”
“You gonna do it?” Jake asks.
“Nah. I told her we were going to celebrate in Tahoe, and she gave up, hinting she couldn’t afford to get there. Guess she wanted me to pay for her?” He snorts.
I inhale sharply, my lungs starting to burn with pain. I’ve never even hinted that he should spend money on me! I’ve always paid my own share. When we were out, we split the bill, even in restaurants that were slightly out of my price range because I didn’t want to appear entitled. That’s one of the reasons we don’t eat out very much—I can’t afford to. My two jobs can barely pay for student loans and rent.
“How pathetic is that?” Alan continues. “Besides, she’d only embarrass me with some cheap shit in front of my family because that’s all she can afford. I almost died when she gave me a watch last Christmas.”
“A watch?” Sean says.
“Yeah, I’ve never seen you wear one,” Jake says.
Alan snorts. “Exactly.” There’s a beat, then all three burst out laughing.
I bite my lip as humiliation burns through me. I saved for months to buy him that watch. When he smiled and thanked me, I thought he loved it. But after noticing that he didn’t wear it, I figured he just wasn’t a watch person and knitted him a sweater this year, believing it’d be a more practical and thoughtful gift.
I’ve been an idiot!
“Why don’t you just dump her?” Sean asks.
“Dude, I’m not a complete asshole. I feel sorry for her. Who’ll date her if I don’t?” Alan says. “She’d die alone, like a stray.”
Blood rushes to my head. The laughter grows and my eyes start to burn with tears. I want to go up to Alan and tell him he’s being totally unfair and wrong, but that’d only make me more pathetic. Might even look clingy.
I shake my head, not even being able to think of anything that could hurt him the way he’s hurting me. My whole system is reeling from the shock of his cruelty. But I’ll be damned if I give him the satisfaction of seeing me cry.
I am not pathetic!
I hug my gifts—he doesn’t deserve them. Nor do his parents for raising such a shitty human being. I made them for a man I thought I could have a future—and family—with. I spin around and leave, not bothering to close the door. If he gets robbed… Oh well, not my problem!
The air in the corridor is chilly, and my cheeks feel icy. Damn it, why am I crying? He isn’t worth the heartache.
I swipe at my face impatiently, then take the stairs down. So many homes have colorful decorations—trees, Santas, reindeer, candy canes—but the lights seem to be blinking Morse code for “You don’t belong anywhere.” I pass a family of three heading to their car.
I slow down and stare at them. The couple smiles indulgently at their little girl’s non-stop chattering. I can’t remember what it’s like to have Christmas anymore. Forget holidays, I can’t even recall what it’s like to have parents.
Mine divorced when I was ten. Although they fought bitterly over custody, it was more about hurting the other party than really wanting me. When the court gave me to Mom, she dumped me on Grandma’s doorstep and disappeared.
Ever since Grandma passed away, I’ve been alone. Mom came by the funeral, but only to say I was old enough to be on my own. She’d moved to San Diego, married some car dealer and had two kids with him. And all that time she never once reached out to me, probably preferring to focus on her new family. I guess they suit her better.
Dad didn’t bother to attend—but then he never contacted me after the divorce. I don’t even know if he’s still alive.
I toss the gifts onto the back seat, then grip the steering wheel and rest my forehead against stiff fingers. I don’t often feel lonely—or at least I tell myself I’m not lonely—but it’s so hard during the holidays. I made a few friends in college, but once everyone started working and got busy, we’ve sort of lost contact. And I’ve been juggling two jobs to pay for rent, groceries, my car and student loan, which leaves very little time to socialize.
When Alan started to flirt with me in Ember & Ivy last year, and then asked me out, I really believed he and I could have a genuine relationship.
I sniffle, then straighten and blow my nose. No more crying. How Alan went from a seemingly sweet boyfriend who brings me flowers to…that in the condo, I’ll never know. But what he said to his friends must be how he really feels. I pinch the bridge of my nose and tell myself that it’s better to find out now what a piece of shit he is than later. But it doesn’t bring much consolation.