I nodded and tried not to hyperventilate. “Thank you for the info. That’s actually super helpful.” He raised his eyebrows at me, and I scoffed. “Don’t worry. I’m not going to do anything stupid.”
Yet.
He shook his head at me. “I was your boyfriend, remember? I can tell when you’re lying.”
“Hey!” I chuckled and lightly swatted his arm. I didn’t miss his use of the past tense though. The word tearing out a tiny sliver of my heart. “Fine. I’ll be careful.”
He smiled and shook his head, hair falling across his brow. “Good. I will always care about you, Ive. And while I can understand why you want to go after them.” He waved his hand toward the front door. “I don’t understand what you hope to achieve by doing so.” His big brown eyes met mine, and for a split second, I saw the boy I fell in love with. The boy who cared so much about everyone else. The boy who’d turned into a loving man that any woman would be lucky to have. A man who could read me like a book and knew exactly where my head had been throughout this conversation.
“It’s not just about….” I waved my hand at the front door too. Unable to say the words we were both thinking. “I need to stop Seth. I can’t let him do this to any other families.”
He rubbed a palm across his face and nodded, unwilling or out of the energy needed to dissuade me. Standing from his chair, he turned to me, arms wide and his mouth tilted up at the corner. “Well, I’d better head back home.”
I pushed myself out of the cold wooden chair and wandered into his outstretched arms. He gently wrapped his arms around me. The light embrace warm and bittersweet.
I sighed and hugged him harder. His shoulders and ribs were so much more pronounced than they had been a year ago.
“Say hi to your parents for me,” I said as he pulled away. I took the moment to have one last really good look at him. His soft brown hair, warm eyes, and the shadows of trauma etched on his skin. The boy next door whose dreamlike life had turned into a nightmare.
“I will.”
He pulled me back in for one more quick squeeze before turning and walking down the steps toward the street.
“Oh, and, Ive.” He stopped halfway down and looked back up. “Two things.”
“Yeah?”
“Thanks for saving me.” He smiled lightly, a friendly warmth filling his brown eyes.
“Of course. You’re welcome,” I sighed and returned the smile. “What’s the second thing?”
“Don’t leave your dirty laundry on the bathroom floor. Put it in the hamper,” he said with a grin. I let out a snort of laughter and waved goodbye to my first love.
37
Ivy
Stepping back into the house, I hung up my jacket and surveyed my surroundings. I didn’t know whether to laugh or cry. My first love had just broken up with me, but the numbing fissure that I was waiting for didn’t appear. The hole that I’d wallowed in for so long after he “died” didn’t return as I stood there, unmoving, waiting for something, anything to happen.
But it didn’t.
I plopped down onto one of the wooden dining chairs and stared at the handbag resting on the dresser by the front door, uncertain if I really wanted to dig deeper into my emotions. The why and, more likely, who was causing the vacillating emotional response sent a shiver down my spine. I’d suffered so much loss over the past few years, so much pain and grief, but… I was still alive. Somehow, I had made some wonderful friends and survived unthinkable pains that could so easily drag you to the deepest depths of the ocean.
Staring at my handbag across the room, still zippered shut with its magical contents hidden from sight, I contemplated my earlier plan and what that might mean. How it would differ with this new information from Cade. What the results of my decisions moving forward would mean for me, my friends, the unsuspecting world. If I dared. If I actually went after the man who deserved to burn in the hottest parts of hell for what he’d done…. What would that do to me? And what about the blue-eyed man? He’d helped me and saved my boyfriend, but who would save him?
I quietly chuckled to myself. It was madness. But… fuck it.
I stood, crossed the room, and opened up my handbag. Pulling out the glossy blue stone from its hiding place, I glanced at it, turning it over and over in my hand. The cold and shiny surface warmed in the heat of my palm.
I steadied my breath and focused on making a portal, the first since Grandma’s death. Mere moments later, a blue geode-like light appeared before me, and I stepped through, hoping it had worked as intended.
“Jesus, you’re just like him!” Grayson squealed, his fists flinching, as I stepped into the twins’ living room. “We’re gonna have to set ground rules for you too.”
I smiled as I stood before the Hale twins. They were both still in their funeral attire, sat with their computers in front of them. “Thank you for coming today.”
“Of course.” Ben smiled lightly.
Even though they lived next door, I hadn’t spoken to them much since the events of that night. I had been too busy dealing with the police and funeral arrangements. So, I’d asked Maya to tell them about everything that I saw when I got home that night—Hunter with Seth, Grandma, the ransacked house. Apparently, Grayson and Ben hadn’t taken the news well. On one hand, their best friend appeared to be a deceitful killer, and on the other, they had lost their friend and neighbor. They had spent hours raging around Maya’s apartment, bickering about theories and trying to defend their friend. The latter had not gone over well with Maya, who eventually shoved them out the door and sent them to the airport. They cooled off during the two-hour flight and called Maya to apologize for being assholes. I fully understood the battle unfolding inside them though. So, they needed to know that their friend wasn’t a complete traitor.