Sweetheart.
When did that start?
I don’t fucking know. And no matter how soft his voice is when he says it, I tell myself that it doesn’t mean anything, even though some wild part of me likes it. It’s another sneaky little FBPI tactic, isn’t it? Like the flirting? Lulling me into a false sense of security so I’ll admit to murder or whatever.
“It’s… crazy,” I whisper. “Maybe I’m crazy.”
I can practically hear that stupid little smirk of his in his voice when he says, “I happen to like crazy.”
Ugh. Okay. I’m really going to have to do this, aren’t I?
YOLO.
I draw in a shuddering breath, and then finally say the words.
“I… I saw it.”
There.
It’s out.
The truth.
Fucking mic-drop, I guess.
Benny shifts, the fabric of his clothes rustling as he moves. His breath slides against the exposed skin of my collarbone, and I shiver.
“Saw it?” he asks. “Like, a vision? Crystal balls, and shit?”
“No,” I force out. “I mean, I don’t know. I don’t…”
And I can’t stop the tears then.
They’re silent, not like the ones I sobbed out earlier while I stayed extremely calm on the phone with Benny, whose thumb is very suddenly on my cheek now, swiping said tears away.
My stomach flips, and it’s not just from fear this time.
Oh, fuck.
“Listen to me, sweetheart,” he says. “Whatever’s going on, I believe you, no matter how insane it’s gonna sound. Hell, I fucking eat crazy for breakfast. So just be honest with me, okay?”
I shudder.
From the way he calls me sweetheart like he means it? From the relief that I somehow actually believe that he believes me? Or from the way his finger lingers on my cheekbone with a gentleness that’s totally at odds with how he’s going to arrest me in about five fucking minutes?
All of the fucking above.
Shit, I’m cooked.
So, I come clean, finally and completely.
“Dreams,” I admit. “Nightmares.”
His thumb stills.
I draw in another unsteady breath and continue, “They, um, start with a migraine. And this… dread. I can’t… I don’t…” I shake my head. “I went to sleep and, um… saw it. Your friend. He was… oh, fuck, he was torn apart…”
Silence creeps into the gap between us as my voice trails off. Part of me desperately wants to open my eyes, to see the disbelief that I know must be written across his face, but I don’t because I’m a big fucking coward.