I offer him a tiny smile, which he returns with one of his usual fangy grins. But I think there’s something tentative about it. Did he expect me to listen to him tell me how he was literally abused in so many ways, and… what? Think less of him for it?
Maybe.
Because isn’t that why I haven’t told Raina the whole truth about Brock?
If she knew, she’d think that I’m irredeemably stupid. Drunk on dumb bitch juice, in fact.
But I think Benny just… knows.
Gets it.
And now, he says, “Tell me what the fuck he did so I can think of some more creative insults for him. I need some better material than fucking phone-jail.”
I laugh, but it’s a little manic because even though this is one of those things I’ve kept buried for way too long, part of me actually wants to just spill the goddamn tea.
His grin widens, like he knows I’m close to cracking.
And you know what?
I am.
I shall channel my best egg self and crack the fuck open, yolk and all.
Hope he likes his Aisling omelet with a side of trauma.
Steeling myself with a deep, shaky breath, I start, “Okay. So. He was, um… fine, at first. Normal. We liked a lot of the same stuff, and he was cute, I guess. It wasn’t like the red flag guy was running around or anything, you know?”
He nods.
“And it started small. Like, he’d, um, make a comment on an outfit that wasn’t outright mean, but… it would make me feel like I had the fashion sense of an entire Muppet. So, I’d change, and just… stop wearing those things. And he liked me to have my location on because he was worried something would happen to me, but then that became asking why I was going to certain places and who I was with. All small stuff. Things that felt reasonable at the time, but looking back… I just keep asking myself how I was so tragically stupid.”
“Boiling frog,” Benny says.
Um… boiling what now?
“Is that, like, some no-cap-Skibidi-aura bullshit?” I ask.
He snorts out a laugh and explains, “No, it’s this weird fucking allegory. You put a frog in a pot of water, and it’s all good vibes and sunshine and unicorn shit at first. Turn the gas on under the pot, and the water gradually starts getting warmer, and the frog adjusts because the change is slow. But by the time it realizes that it’s hotter than Satan’s fucking ass crack in there, it’s too late. Water’s boiling. Frog fucking soup.”
I narrow my eyes. “So you’re saying I’m a frog in Satan’s ass crack.”
“A very pretty frog in Satan’s ass crack,” he amends with another cheeky grin.
Excuse me, but did he just call me pretty? In a weird and possibly insulting sort of way?
“What I mean is that the water was fucking fine when you got in,” he continues. “How were you supposed to know he’d turn on the goddamn gas?”
I… guess that makes sense.
But weren’t there signs? And once we started living together…
Fresh anxiety slides between my ribs.
Benny inhales and then squeezes my hand, just a little. Does he smell how much this eats at me?
I draw in another deep breath.
It really is fucking honesty hour, isn’t it? Here goes nothing, I guess.