Footsteps. “I think Finley was about ten there. He’d make a fuss every time Iris tried to get him in for a haircut that year. I think that’s as long as it got.”
I know the picture now. The four of us are sitting on the dock, backing the lake, waiting for the timer to go off on the camera Dad would prop up on a chair. My hair was shoulder length. I loved it.
“She would have us take this same picture at the end of every summer, right before we got into the car to head home.”
It’s subtle, but I catch it. Dad’s voice rising a decibel or two.
“What the hell is happening?” Hayley mouths at me.
I shake my head. “No fucking idea.”
“The way Finn speaks about her, she sounds like she was an incredible mother.”
There’s a long silence after that. Hayley bulges her eyes at me, and with a flash of dread, I turn to go in there and break this up. I don’t even turn off the tap. She shouldn’t have brought Mom up. There’s a reason we don’t bring her up around Dad. He’s bad enough, doesn’t need any setbacks—
Hayley grabs my arm and keeps me still.
There’s the sound of wood clapping on wood. The picture frame coming down on the credenza.
“She was a great mother,” Dad says.
“I never had that,” Jenna says quietly, and my heart throbs for her.
“You didn’t?” Dad’s voice has grown a little louder.
“My mom wasn’t involved. I wasn’t hard done by or anything. But growing up was nothing how Finn describes it.”
“He tells you about her?” Dad’s question rings in my ears. Or rather, the tone of his voice does. It’s heavy, forlorn. Envious.
Hayley’s hand slips into mine. She’s frowning.
“Sometimes,” Jenna tells Dad, and her voice is soft. She can tell she’s hit on something. “Sometimes on purpose. Other times it just slips out when he isn’t thinking too hard.”
“What does he say about her?”
“He tells me how nurturing she was. How she cared a lot that they were raised right, but gave them room to find a little trouble, too. There was one story, when she caught Finn sneaking out of his window—”
I rear like I’ve been punched straight in the gut. Because he just—
Dad just—
Hayley’s hand squeezes mine, and when I turn to look, her eyes are brimming with tears. Dad just laughed. It was short, wheezy, rusty like he hasn’t emitted that kind of sound in a while. Like his body is trying to remember how it goes.
I’m shaking. It’s adrenaline, but something that feels pretty awful too.
“She’d never admit it to his face, but it was one of Iris’s favorite stories,” Dad’s saying. “To this day I don’t have the foggiest idea where the hell it is that boy went. But he showed up a couple hours later with a broken nose, face all bloodied up, asking for a ride to the hospital.”
Jenna knows the full story, the parts Dad doesn’t. She laughs, though, delighted by his retelling. I can see her dimple through the drywall.
“Iris never asked either, what it is he got up to. She was making a point. That he could come to us in a pinch without ever worrying he’d take crap for it.” Dad pauses, and when he speaks again, there’s something a little playful in his voice. “You know where he went, don’t you?”
Jenna chuckles. “I’ve been sworn to secrecy. Did he really never get into trouble for it?”
“Oh, he was doing our dishes for a good month afterward. Not that he complained. He knew better. But the boy never snuck out again.”
“That you know of,” Jenna singsongs, and I picture her giving my dad that little conspiratorial nudge she does. The one that makes you feel like you’re on the same team. Like you’re someone important.
“That we know of,” Dad agrees. “I still have the old photos, if you want to see them. The ones from the end of summer.”