I swallow. Pretty or not, Finn hurting isn’t a sight I ever want to witness. “I’m sure. Theo, I really…” I gesture helplessly at my chest.
“Okay.” He nods. “For the record, I think you’d be great together. If you can’t pull this off with him, I don’t think anyone ever will.”
I flush. “Alright, alright, I get it: you’re a nice guy, Theo. You’ve officially got my blessing to marry our girl. But do it within the next month, won’t you? And have you considered eloping?”
“Enough about this bet,” Jude groans. She takes Theo’s hand, tugging him and his incredibly baffled expression out of the office. “Ignore her. She’s so lovesick she doesn’t know what she’s saying.”
I rush behind them and give Jude a playful slap on the ass. “I’m not in love.”
“Yet,” she throws over her shoulder.
As we near the swinging doors that lead into the kitchen, I hear Finn’s loud, deep laugh go off inside. I adore his laugh. Every single time, he sounds like he’s just been told the funniest joke he’s ever heard. He laughs with total abandon, like he’s trying to absorb the joy out of every little moment and give it back to you even bigger, in the form of that laugh.
As though my thoughts conjured him up, the doors open and I stop dead in my tracks as Finn backs out of the kitchen. “You’re on solo cleaning duty tomorrow if I see you come in late again—” He backs right into me so hard I have to catch myself on a nearby chair.
“Watch where you’re going, kid,” I say, smoothing down my hair. “I didn’t dress like this to get trampled.”
Finn pivots around so quickly I catch the laugh fade off his face. His expression veers from surprise right into his signature grin. The lopsided one I can’t get enough of.
“Woah. You’re here. I was just about to call you.” He shows me his phone with my contact pulled up. His gaze trails behind me, presumably finding Jude and Theo hovering nearby. “Everything okay?”
“We came to wrangle Theo from the back office,” I tell him. “He was sending SOS signals through ESP.”
“Oh. He should have joined us in the kitchen. We just finished a round of Never Have I Ever.” Finn sends an innocent look over my shoulder, and chuckles at what I can only assume is a thoroughly unamused expression from Theo.
“Are you done, too?” I ask him.
“Yeah, you’re right on time. Want a ride home?”
Home. I don’t know exactly when it happened, him switching from my place to home, but I like it a lot more than I should. I feel it more than I should. Like it makes perfect sense for me to be there.
I can feel Jude’s eyes burning holes into my back. “Finn, I’m about to become your… second favorite person.”
He flashes her a quick smile over my shoulder. “Ah, you’re selling yourself short, honey.”
“Am I?” she says loftily, and I refuse to turn around to see exactly why Finn’s mouth hardens into a line. “Anyway, I just got you out of work Friday night. We’re all going for drinks.”
Finn’s eyes meet mine. “And why does it feel like I’m being stalked by a Jude-shaped shark?”
He’s dropped his voice like he’s only talking to me, and takes a little, conspiratorial step towards me. Like whatever game Jude’s playing, he and I are in it together. I take a tiny step forward too.
“Just go with it. Her wide-eyed, sweet and innocent thing is a total act. Apparently, she did this really filthy thing to Theo in the backseat of his car—”
“Watch it,” Theo says sharply from behind me.
I snort. “And he refuses to let her tell me what it was.”
Theo wheels a cackling Jude toward the exit, grumbling about driving them straight to a deserted parking lot to collect his dues.
“See you Friday night, boss,” Finn calls after them, waving them off with just enough enthusiasm to get a rise out of Theo. As soon as they’re out of sight, he touches a hand to my hip, bringing his lips to my forehead. “We’ll get him to spill. Just wait and see.”
He leads me out behind them, and a single thought pops into my mind as we meet the warm summer night:
I’ll get you to love me. Just wait and see.
Chapter 15
Finn