~
“We’ll take them all.”
Finn stands in front of the display counter of Hanna’s Bake Shoppe, staring down at the rainbow of cupcakes through the glass, hands planted on his hips as though to signal that he truly means business.
The shop assistant stands frozen in front of him, looking like she can’t decide whether she’s the subject of some bizarre prank. Tucked a little behind him, I can’t help but giggle at the scene. He peeks over his shoulder at the sound, flashing me a grin.
“You… want to buy all the cupcakes? All of them?” the shop assistant asks.
“All of them,” Finn confirms, waving along the counter. “Every single one. And we’ll eat them there.” He jabs a thumb over his shoulder, indicating a booth along the back wall of the pastel-colored shop.
“But…” The young girl stares down at the display. “There has to be, like, fifty cupcakes here.”
“Seems like a nice number. And why don’t we throw in a chocolate éclair while we’re at it. Do you like éclairs, Jenna Bear?”
“I love éclairs.”
“Two chocolate éclairs, please.”
The shop assistant’s gaze slides over to meet mine, as though to verify that she isn’t dealing with a madman. I’m not entirely sure I can accurately answer that question, as it stands. Finn’s mood seems to have veered into an unprecedented level of enthusiasm on the car ride over. To be fair, mine has managed to pull in that direction, too. We took a long detour along the freeway with the top down on the way here, and my reflection in the glass display shows me just how insane my hair is right now.
Apparently, the shop assistant decides it’s probably safest to just give the nutter his fifty cupcakes and two éclairs. Finn nods at the purple nylon-covered booth behind us and follows me in, balancing five cupcake boxes and a paper plate of éclairs the size of my head. He lays it all out on the table between us, our overzealous sugar feast, opening all the boxes as though he really expects us to gorge on all this in one sitting.
He hands me an éclair and bumps it with the one he’s holding. “Cheers.”
And he smothers the thing into his mouth with so much force, the custard squirts out of the other end so heartily I dodge the stream with a squeak.
“Fuck, that’s good stuff,” he says, mouth so full I’m not exactly sure how he manages the words, or how I manage to make out the garbled syllables. “Dig in, Jenna Bear, or I’m coming for yours next.”
You know what’s hard? Eating while you’re smiling.
So hard that a little dribble of custard leaks out of the corner of my mouth as I chew the pastry. Finn keeps his eyes on me, returning my smile until I manage to swallow. Satisfied, he pulls a cupcake out of one of the boxes laid out between us and smashes the remaining half of his éclair down onto the icing.
“Now this?” he says, lifting his concoction, icing oozing onto his fingers. “This might be my best creation yet. To hell with my award-winning dishes. Frankencake beats them all.”
A couple walks past our table, and the woman’s head turns at the declaration. She eyes his Frankencake dubiously.
“Give me that,” I say, grabbing for it. I have to open my mouth as wide as it will go to get it in, and when I do, the combination of vanilla frosting and chocolate and custard dribbles over my chin.
“Well?”
“Yeah.” I nod, swallowing the soft mess of vanilla and pastry. “Honestly, it’s so gross it’s kind of amazing.”
“God, I’m good. Make a note to tell Theo he owes me a raise. He doesn’t know how lucky he is to have me.” He reaches over the table to dislodge frosting off my chin with his thumb, licking off what he collects. My gaze snags on the tiny fleck of icing he leaves behind on his bottom lip.
“You have…” I reach for it without thinking, lifting the frosting off his soft, pillowy lower lip. I lick it off my own thumb.
I’ll make you crave me so bad you’ll be screaming my name in your dreams.
It’s a lot more pleasant than that usual voice in my head. That hot discomfort between my thighs resurfaces every time that line hits, since the moment Finn whispered it in my ear weeks ago.
I’ve never ached for someone this badly. And what’s funny is… the more of Finn I get to know, the worse it gets.
At this point, I make myself come to the thought of him every single night. And still, I’ve woken up mid-orgasm enough times to wonder if it’s possible he hasn’t heard me in my sleep by now. I can’t remember the last wet dream I had before moving in with him.
“Don’t.” Finn looks like he’s descended deep into the same ocean of lust where I find myself, all hard eyes and stiff shoulders as he stares across the table. “Jenna, please. Don’t do that.”
I realize I’m licking my lips again. I make myself stop. “I swear that was an accident,” I tell him, grabbing a napkin. “I’ve been trying really hard to be good.”