Her lips twitch. “Smithson’s Pale Ale. You had a couple before switching to a strawberry daiquiri.”
I grin, twisting off the top to one of the Smithson’s and handing it to her. “Excuse me. It was a cosmo. I like to think only a secure man would have the balls to order that in front of a woman he was trying to sleep with. Plus, they’re delicious.”
“Hey, no justification needed. It was kind of the perfect move. A total nice guy drink to lull me into a sense of security before you tried to kidnap me.”
It’s a relief, knowing I’m not the only one who keeps that night on replay. But what’s more than a little worrisome is that it’s the little details of it that come to mind for me. That first smile she gave me when she and Jude approached the table where I sat with Theo, pure confidence though she didn’t know either one of us. The way the passing streetlights fell across her face in the back of the cab we thought was taking us back to my place, and not out in the middle of the country where it stranded us. How soft she felt when I passed out spooning her, both dressed from head to toe, too exhausted to act on the flirtation after hitching a ride back into the city.
She’s existed in my memory like a mythical force, who stormed into my life to unsettle me for a night before disappearing into thin air.
Jenna takes a long sip of her beer, eyes on mine as I sink down on the other end of the sofa. “So, what’s new, Jenna? How was the trip?”
She watches me fiddle with the label on my bottle. I make myself stop. “It was amazing. I’ve never traveled alone before, but there’s really something to it. Definitely tops sitting behind a reception desk all day.”
I let out a low whistle. “Wish I coulda witnessed the damage you did. Jenna Bear out in the wild.”
She grins around the lip of her bottle at the silly nickname I came up with the last time I saw her. Like a sexy mama bear, I told her of the way she protected her friend, when Theo had been a predictable headcase that night.
“I picked up a few new friends here and there, so half the time it turned into a girls’ trip. Honestly, it’s kind of nice to be home.”
“Are you staying put for a while, then?”
She gives me a knowing smile. “I’m only here for my sister’s wedding. A couple months and I fly back, straight to Portugal.”
This is it: my white whale. No need even for the this-is-just-sex conversation because she pre-empts it with a clear declaration of her own.
So… what was that uncomfortable twinge in the pit of my stomach?
I shake myself mentally. There’s a stunning, playful, ready and willing woman sitting on my sofa, in my apartment. If I screw this one up? I’ll check myself into a monastery for the rest of eternity.
“Where are you staying in the meantime?”
“With Jude and Theo. What are you watching?”
I glance at the TV just as a net full of thrashing fish rises from the ocean on screen.
Shit.
“Nothing, I…” I grapple for the remote sitting between us, but Jenna snatches it up first and flicks up the sound. Stomach sinking, I clear my throat and nudge my glasses a fraction up my nose. “It’s a documentary on fish farms along—”
“The Pacific Ocean,” she finishes with unmistakable enthusiasm, turning in her seat to face the TV. “I watched it on the flight home. I never knew I could develop such strong feelings about tilapia.”
“Does anyone have strong feelings about tilapia? It’s the plain white bread of the ocean. Zero flavor and kind of unpleasant unless it’s toasted and slathered in jam.”
She frowns laughingly. “Jam? Really?”
I settle into the sofa cushion, taking a deep drink from my beer. “Preferably apricot.”
“Apricot?” She’s really laughing now. “God, I need to get out of here. Who knew you were such a freak—”
Jenna makes to get up from the sofa but I lunge for her, taking hold of her waist and tugging her down on my lap.
“Not so fast,” I mutter in her ear, and with a breathy giggle that does something wicked to the lower half of my body, she sinks back into my chest. “I don’t like watching scary movies alone. Stay and hold my hand a little.”
“Scary movies?”
“You don’t find the systematic destruction of the earth’s bodies of water scary?”
She throws me a funny look over her shoulder. “When you put it like that…”